I never said Year One was realistic though. You made that claim, not I. I like that story for different reasons not, "OMG, these things could really happen". That doesn't seem to be the point of Year One imo.
Besides, I stated, "wahhh, wahh, dis isn't da cromics, dis is Nolen's reelistic aht, his interpretation of betmen".
It's his interpretation of Batman, not Frank Millers, not vice versa. I might be wrong, but I never saw him breaking no brick walls or tree trunks in Begins or TDK. When people saw him do that in TDKR, SUSPENSION DISBELIEF FAILED.
Besides, that's one of many problems with TDKR that people have, nit picks or not. Double standards? What if people simply just don't like TDKR and what it has to offer? Hating to hate? Nahhh. The movie is weird bull**** to some folks, let em be.