The Official "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" movie thread *SPOILERS*

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Started a speed read of the hobbit again today to get in the mood, half way through already it really is a short book:horror
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

I got the One Ring laynard with the show times on the back as well as the Bilbo Hobbit key chain at the trilogy last night. That's probably because I saw it at AMC.

I'm actually surprised I lasted all three films. By mid Two Towers, I was completely butt hurt. I had to run around for about an hour during the break, I felt like crap. I was surprised by the turn out, it was completely packed at my showings, kids and adults, and they all stayed. Return of the King . . . damn. It's great but, what a bloated film. It's full of fat that needed to be trimmed (even the non Extended Edition). I was getting really anxious with the last 40 minutes, "c'mon, stop ****ing around and end it".

Great stuff though, but I'm probably never going to watch LOTR again. :lol







Oh and Fellowship of the Ring is clearly the best in my eyes. Best pacing, they're all together, Moria, Amon Hen, Boromir, Gandalf the Grey, the Shire, it can't be beat.
 
Last edited:
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Yeah when I watch ROTK now I just skip through all the Frodo and Sam parts to the action scenes, they just went overboard with the hurl inducing bromance once they get into mordor:lol
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

The reviews have been pretty mixed though, surprisingly

Not surprised and its really a small portion when you look at most of the reviews out there. Also the negative stuff seems to be more aimed at the 48fps (which will only be Ina very small % of theaters world wide).
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

I got the One Ring laynard with the show times on the back as well as the Bilbo Hobbit key chain at the trilogy last night. That's probably because I saw it at AMC.

I'm actually surprised I lasted all three films. By mid Two Towers, I was completely butt hurt. I had to run around for about an hour during the break, I felt like crap. I was surprised by the turn out, it was completely packed at my showings, kids and adults, and they all stayed. Return of the King . . . damn. It's great but, what a bloated film. It's full of fat that needed to be trimmed (even the non Extended Edition). I was getting really anxious with the last 40 minutes, "c'mon, stop ****ing around and end it".

Great stuff though, but I'm probably never going to watch LOTR again. :lol

Oh and Fellowship of the Ring is clearly the best in my eyes. Best pacing, they're all together, Moria, Amon Hen, Boromir, Gandalf the Grey, the Shire, it can't be beat.

:rotfl:rotfl

Yeah, I can only watch all 3 EE once every 1.5 to 2 years.

What a bunch of pansies. :nana: I pretty much do this every year at home so this wasn't a big deal. The hour between each movie gave me a nice break to walk around.

FOTR is amazing but equally so is ROTK IMO. I don't feel it's bloated at all. The added depth of the EE material just sets this film off to be as awesome as it is.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Not surprised and its really a small portion when you look at most of the reviews out there. Also the negative stuff seems to be more aimed at the 48fps (which will only be Ina very small % of theaters world wide).

Actually most of the negativity seems to be around the pacing - that it feels unnecessarily drawn out

61% on metacritic and 75% on RT so far - will struggle to match up to the original trilogy it seems at least in terms of critical reception
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Actually most of the negativity seems to be around the pacing - that it feels unnecessarily drawn out

61% on metacritic and 75% on RT so far - will struggle to match up to the original trilogy it seems at least in terms of critical reception

Yeah, that has been mentioned but most of it I coming at the 48fps. I've made an effort to read a lot of the reviews so I feel confident saying what I'm saying. Also the drawn out stuff is coming from people who don't get that the appendices material was added.

I don't give a flying flip flop about either of those. I put no stock in either measure at all.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

I don't pay attention to reviews anyway, I'm never gonna have the exact same feelings about a film as some random paid journalist, or anyone else for that matter.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

I don't pay attention to reviews anyway, I'm never gonna have the exact same feelings about a film as some random paid journalist, or anyone else for that matter.

How can anyone, hell, I still firmly believe Blade 1 to be one of the best Marvel movies yet.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

What a bunch of pansies. :nana: I pretty much do this every year at home so this wasn't a big deal. The hour between each movie gave me a nice break to walk around.

FOTR is amazing but equally so is ROTK IMO. I don't feel it's bloated at all. The added depth of the EE material just sets this film off to be as awesome as it is.

Still, I get where they're coming from. At times, I was more focused on how long it would be until I can go to the bathroom again, than the movie.:lol
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Still, I get where they're coming from. At times, I was more focused on how long it would be until I can go to the bathroom again, than the movie.:lol

I don't worry about that. I've seen each film at least 20 times so I just get up and go. I know whats going on in the story. :lol
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

I actually fell asleep the first(and only time) I watched Return of the King previously.:horror Suffice it to say, my Soda went largely untouched.:lol Did you see it in IMAX or was it only in regular theaters? My Cinemark had it on the big XD screen, which was really cool to experience, as I was a little late to the LotR game, so I'd never seen them on the big screen before.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

I actually fell asleep the first(and only time) I watched Return of the King previously.:horror Suffice it to say, my Soda went largely untouched.:lol Did you see it in IMAX or was it only in regular theaters? My Cinemark had it on the big XD screen, which was really cool to experience, as I was a little late to the LotR game, so I'd never seen them on the big screen before.

It wasn't IMAX but it was in their next biggest screen room (same room I'm seeing The Hobbit in). There's no way I could fall a sleep during these movies. These to me (for me I should say) are m top three movies ever. There is no trilogy right now that can even sniff them. Between releases now I've seen each one in the theater a few times. Better late than never.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

I got the One Ring laynard with the show times on the back as well as the Bilbo Hobbit key chain at the trilogy last night. That's probably because I saw it at AMC.

I'm actually surprised I lasted all three films. By mid Two Towers, I was completely butt hurt. I had to run around for about an hour during the break, I felt like crap. I was surprised by the turn out, it was completely packed at my showings, kids and adults, and they all stayed. Return of the King . . . damn. It's great but, what a bloated film. It's full of fat that needed to be trimmed (even the non Extended Edition). I was getting really anxious with the last 40 minutes, "c'mon, stop ****ing around and end it".

Great stuff though, but I'm probably never going to watch LOTR again. :lol







Oh and Fellowship of the Ring is clearly the best in my eyes. Best pacing, they're all together, Moria, Amon Hen, Boromir, Gandalf the Grey, the Shire, it can't be beat.

Yeah when I watch ROTK now I just skip through all the Frodo and Sam parts to the action scenes, they just went overboard with the hurl inducing bromance once they get into mordor:lol

this is pure blasphemy! :horror

I think if anything for me Two Towers is the one that has some long scenes like Treebeard, some stuff in Two Towers feels a little long

but Return of the King is perfect. Specially because it has my favorite scene when Frodo and Sam go into Mordor and dress in the Orcish armor. I LOVE that part. I Love Return you guys are nuts :lol


What a bunch of pansies. :nana: I pretty much do this every year at home so this wasn't a big deal. The hour between each movie gave me a nice break to walk around.

FOTR is amazing but equally so is ROTK IMO. I don't feel it's bloated at all. The added depth of the EE material just sets this film off to be as awesome as it is.

I agree I also love seeing the mouth of Sauron in the EE, such a vile but awesome creature
3841843_o.gif
 
Back
Top