No, you’re correct. You absolutely can’t say that people who are living now are responsible for them, but what you can do is point out discrepancies in the ways that things that occurred generations ago have impacted people from different cultures in different ways and how white america is either purposefully obtuse to the fact that their cultural experience might not reflect that of someone else’s or the fact that they just don’t care, and, in my mind, both of those attitudes are inherently damaging.
Hell, we like to talk about how the marginalization of Native Americans is in the past, yet, here we are, in 2017, taking what little land they have afforded to them and running a ****ing pipeline through it.
It seems to me like the biggest problem faced by white people in America, today, is being made to feel uncomfortable about ****ing anything in relation to themselves. I’ll be straight with you, I’m a white, heterosexual male college student: that means I am an utter cliché, but, ultimately, I don’t see the racial problem in America as some incredibly complex issue that’s impossible to solve; I think it goes back to something my mother taught me as a kid, and something i’m sure many mothers have taught their children: “don’t judge a man until you’ve walked a mile in his shoes,” and that idea is nearly universal in its application. When you look at our government, in relation to LGBTQ rights, in relation to women’s reproductive rights, in relation to minorities and, even, religious rights, time and again, there’s this picture of condescension. That “I’m a 70 year old white man and I know what’s best for you.”
I don’t know why this **** is such an issue. I really don’t. If someone is black, and days that, as a black person, they face a problem, who am I to question that, when I can never experience what they have experienced in a context relevant to that person’s experience?