Which "Battle" Droid would you like to see in PF first?

[King Darkness]

yeah he's retarded. anyone thats looking forward to the next star trek movie really shouldnt be allowed to talk.

 

[Bonehead15]

yeah he's retarded. anyone thats looking forward to the next star trek movie really shouldnt be allowed to talk.

BURRRNNN.

 

[Anakin]

yeah he's retarded. anyone thats looking forward to the next star trek movie really shouldnt be allowed to talk.

:chew

 

[Anakin]

None actually. I don't think they are cool enough, there are plenty of other characters they could do. But I would pick OG BattleDroid if I had to.

,...none for me also,...

 

[Agent0028]

(*Note: This is regarding PF only, not 1/6, or the desire not to see one at all.*)

 

[Collector Freak]

Yoda?

No. Yoda jumping around fighting like a frog. And not even winning one fight. If he's such an esteemed fighter, why can't he beat anyone? He let Dooky escape and ran away for inSidious.

 

[Bannister]

No. Yoda jumping around fighting like a frog. And not even winning one fight. If he's such an esteemed fighter, why can't he beat anyone? He let Dooky escape and ran away for inSidious.

He ran away from sidious because sidious had the high ground.

 

[hairlesswookiee]

No. Yoda jumping around fighting like a frog. And not even winning one fight. If he's such an esteemed fighter, why can't he beat anyone? He let Dooky escape and ran away for inSidious.

im pretty sure yoda was winning the fight with dooku when he had to rip the beam from the ceiling to crush obi wan and anakin so he could retreat.

and yoda had no choice but run after he fell, why risk jumping all the way back up there..when sidious would be able to throw more seats at him... and oh yeah lets not forget about the shocktroopers that came in too. thats why he was the master and not some ******* that would run into a fight that he would have zero chances on winning at that point.

why was palpatine trying to run away from yoda before the fight even started???

 

[Agent0028]

and yoda had no choice but run after he fell, why risk jumping all the way back up there..when sidious would be able to throw more seats at him... and oh yeah lets not forget about the shocktroopers that came in too. thats why he was the master and not some ******* that would run into a fight that he would have zero chances on winning at that point.

I agree, although I do wonder why after after Obi thought Anakin was defeated he and Yoda didn't go open a can of whoopass on Palpatine. But I just leave this in the same place that I wonder why Obi was able to defeat Grievous after Obi and Ani together couldn't. It just makes it a more fun movie.

 

[hairlesswookiee]

I agree, although I do wonder why after after Obi thought Anakin was defeated he and Yoda didn't go open a can of whoopass on Palpatine. But I just leave this in the same place that I wonder why Obi was able to defeat Grievous after Obi and Ani together couldn't. It just makes it a more fun movie.

thats the only major problem i had with the fights in the movie. in the other two prequels the Jedi had no problem double teaming their opponents, heck even 4 on one with palpatine. but for some reason Yoda said "We must divide our forces!! Instead of just heading over to the Senate building together right now, i want you to go after Anakin so i have Palpatine, his guards and who knows what else-- all to myself!!!"

 

[bcm77]

If I had to choose I'd go for a Destroyer Droid as there hasn't been a large scale one of any kind as yet but to be honest there are many more characters I'd like to see as a PF than any of the PT droid troops.

 

[Collector Freak]

Episode 3 had some of the worst realized fights. The 4 Jedi VS inSidious should have been amazing, but he took them all out like a bunch of ******* in the first 5 seconds. Absolute shiiiiiit.

The final duel was supposed to be amazing, instead they have Obi-Wan and Anakin jumping from platform to platform performing aerobics and gymnastics. Even some baton swinging.

They say that Nick Gillard was the best thing to happen to the prequels, but the only good fight he coordinated was in Episode 1.

 

[King Darkness]

The 4 Jedi VS inSidious should have been amazing, but he took them all out like a bunch of ******* in the first 5 seconds.

No body panic, but I'am gonna agree with Collector Freak ....But your right here, IMO...I was really hoping we were gonna see a kick ass 4 on 1 saber battle. His later battle with Yoda showed some skills, but I think the arrest scene could have been so much better!!!

 

[hairlesswookiee]

i agree when i read the book i was expecting so much more out of the 4 on 1 fight, but lucas really couldnt have made that fight last 10 minutes on top of the mace/palpatine/anakin encounter.

and i was happy with the obi wan and anakin fight until the end "i have the high ground" b.s.

 

[Khev]

and i was happy with the obi wan and anakin fight until the end "i have the high ground" b.s.

True, tactically, having "the high ground" doesn't seem to matter much in SW (just ask :maul ), but Ewan McGregor's delivery of that line was *so* pitch perfect that for me it plays like he's just saying anything he can think of to get Anakin to back down. Then in desperation he actually miraculously takes Anakin out.

I love, love, LOVE the Mustafar duel. It was everything I could have ever anticipated and more. Plus I love how nicely it plays into the ROTJ duel between Luke and Vader. When Luke backflips onto that catwalk above Vader's head he doesn't carelessly let the Mustafar finale repeat itself, he just throws his blade and brings Luke right back down.

The Palpatine 4 on 1 definitely wasn't that great, heck I'm not even a huge fan of the Mace/Palps 1 on 1 either (the digital Palpatine inserts are a little jarring), but when Anakin shows up it totally makes up for it.

The Yoda/Sidious fight was great though.

 

[hairlesswookiee]

True, tactically, having "the high ground" doesn't seem to matter much in SW (just ask :maul ), but Ewan McGregor's delivery of that line was *so* pitch perfect that for me it plays like he's just saying anything he can think of to get Anakin to back down. Then in desperation he actually miraculously takes Anakin out.

I love, love, LOVE the Mustafar duel. It was everything I could have ever anticipated and more. Plus I love how nicely it plays into the ROTJ duel between Luke and Vader. When Luke backflips onto that catwalk above Vader's head he doesn't carelessly let the Mustafar finale repeat itself, he just throws his blade and brings Luke right back down.

The Palpatine 4 on 1 definitely wasn't that great, heck I'm not even a huge fan of the Mace/Palps 1 on 1 either (the digital Palpatine inserts are a little jarring), but when Anakin shows up it totally makes up for it.

The Yoda/Sidious fight was great though.

right on khev!! i think the mustafar duel was really the most emotional out of every other fight. especially for people that have never seen the originals. i pride myself on introducing a couple of people to the SW world. and im glad im not the only person that noticed the ROTJ tie-in either.

 

[TheScarecrow]

hmm. Honestly they should do a something more along the lines like grievous vs shaak ti. They should have all three together in a battle ready pose, fighting side-by-side kind of like this

 

[DarthChrisDK]

Holy Necro-post, Batman! You managed to dig up an 8 year old thread, lol!

 

[TheScarecrow]

wow lol. honestly, I didnt even read the latest post date! My bad!

 

[wbeem]

hmm. Honestly they should do a something more along the lines like grievous vs shaak ti.

Well, they do have a diorama of Grievous vs. Shaak Ti. It probably would have sold better if they sculpted her in a thong, like the PF.