ajp4mgs
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jul 10, 2017
- Messages
- 2,305
- Reaction score
- 1,672
This is the case for any highly over-exposed character.
I think it is the suit and cape that throws me off the most. Perhaps if he really looked like an alien -- something unusual, not a monster, not a bug... just different, then I would be willing to explore the immigration policies you suggest.
But didn't Zach tiptoe on that stuff already? Didn't the MCU build a world around the idea of super beings and how they are outsiders? X-men, etc... it is the defining storyline of comics... along with What is Justice and Who Should Wield It.
Snyder did indeed tiptoe around some of it, but was saddled with what I believe were clunky screenplays (for the most part). He and Terrio seem to have trouble leaving things out and streamlining the narrative. It's like the thinking is that there's no such thing as too many plot threads. Terrio did the same thing, IMO, with Rise of Skywalker. So many plot points that should get proper foundation first, then thematic resolution upon completion, are ultimately left half baked in order to get a reasonable runtime for the movie to play to a mass audience.
I think the tiptoeing that you refer to happened primarily in BvS. But the third act of that film had to take a major pivot to introduce Doomsday and the typical "battle to the death" (as we also got with Zod in MoS before that). For whatever reason, the Death of Superman story had to get crammed into the film. Along the way, Wonder Woman also had to be established in order to set up the Justice League. The narrative focus got diluted to a certain extent. These things complicate how much can be extracted from thematic groundwork to pay it off with a focused resolution at the climax. It just ends up being more setup for later, and then ultimately a departure in part.
Whatever themes were explored about Superman as a superior being having to fit in a world that's not quite sure how to react to that, those were never resolved to the fullest because he had to go fight other aliens (Zod, Doomsday, & Steppenwolf). It's no longer just "how does Superman fit?" but rather "what do all these gods among men mean for the world now?"
I think there's a lot to explore with Superman that would be anything but juvenile, and also less redundant with respect to how the MCU presents its superhero outsiders. But it just might not be what Superman audiences want.