Just going by what I'm seeing.
The most egregious part about it from an accuracy perspective, might be the lining. But I also don't like the appearance of the whole thing in general.
I grabbed some pictures I could find from Facebook.
Here, Guillaume compares it to the Hot Toys cape on the right. Look at the volume, and those folds around the collar on the stock cape. That's closer to what I'm looking for.
View attachment 721781
I'm sure in part, this is worsened on the custom by some poor futzing. But there's no getting around it.
Wrong lining. Less bulk. Almost no definition. And if you look at it really... it just hangs like a folded piece of paper.
View attachment 721782
View attachment 721783