Scout Trooper
š
****.. What happened?This is the only Inart figure I've received with an actual QC issueHopefully I can get a replacement sword soon
I won't be able to inspect my figure until the end of the month probably.
I'm terrified.
InArt: The Lord of the Rings - Aragorn 1:6
- Thread starter Shoo
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
I won't be able to inspect my figure until the end of the month probably.
I'm terrified.
- Joined
- Jun 4, 2011
- Messages
- 600
- Reaction score
- 1,393
my issue was one I haven't seen anyone else say, but the tip of the sword was chipped off in the package. no idea what could have caused that to happen.
Edit: I wouldn't worry too much @Scout Trooper even with that issue this figure is one of my all time favorites.
Totally fair. I just think certain collectors have insane and unreasonable standards set for themselves with INART figs, which will lead to disappointment. Like you said, itās as good as it gets for a licensed (mass produced) figure, despite inaccuracies or other design flaws they may have.
INARTās QC is an issue no doubt. They need to standardize their QC processes across all factories they employ. And it seems like they're not all in check yet.
I haven't said anything about being dissatisfied with this Aragorn figure which is what @Scout Trooper was referencing, not other figures. Just b/c I agreed with a lot of Brett's points, doesn't mean I don't like this release. Heck, I spent hours redoing the hair on this figure
And I mentioned that I was thankful I didn't get any QC problems with this figure.Harry Potter was the one I expected more from since I did have QC issues (regardless if they are perceived by others as minor or otherwise); though, I've mentioned in that thread that I've come around on it after spending more time on it.
TDK Joker I've been disappointed with since the get go and still am. I'm only keeping for the accessories and the thought of getting the heads redone.
I've had an overall positive impression of Superman and have said as much in my review despite having to scrub that paint off the eyeballs along with a few other things that aren't great on it.
Just b/c you're more forgiving of the QC issues that some of us have experienced, doesn't make them any less valid of a reason(s) for being disappointed with what we're receiving when they occur.
Iām aware Scout is referencing Aragorn in particular, but the sentiment he referenced can essentially be applied to all INART figures, IMO.I haven't said anything about being dissatisfied with this Aragorn figure which is what @Scout Trooper was referencing, not other figures. Just b/c I agreed with a lot of Brett's points, doesn't mean I don't like this release. Heck, I spent hours redoing the hair on this figure
Harry Potter was the one I expected more from since I did have QC issues (regardless if they are perceived by others as minor or otherwise); though, I've mentioned in that thread that I've come around on it after spending more time on it.
TDK Joker I've been disappointed with since the get go and still am. I'm only keeping for the accessories and the thought of getting the heads redone.
I've had an overall positive impression of Superman and have said as much in my review despite having to scrub that paint off the eyeballs along with a few other things that aren't great on it.
Just b/c you're more forgiving of the QC issues that some of us have experienced, doesn't make them any less valid of a reason(s) for being disappointed with what we're receiving when they occur.
And I shouldāve expanded, but this goes out to anyone and everyone, not specifically singling you out.
I do think some collectors have an even higher standard which of course, is a set up for failure ending with disappointment.
- Joined
- Jun 4, 2011
- Messages
- 600
- Reaction score
- 1,393
as an aside @Gipetto0812 do you have any pics of your old MoS custom? been thinking about getting that figure done.I haven't said anything about being dissatisfied with this Aragorn figure which is what @Scout Trooper was referencing, not other figures. Just b/c I agreed with a lot of Brett's points, doesn't mean I don't like this release. Heck, I spent hours redoing the hair on this figure
Harry Potter was the one I expected more from since I did have QC issues (regardless if they are perceived by others as minor or otherwise); though, I've mentioned in that thread that I've come around on it after spending more time on it.
TDK Joker I've been disappointed with since the get go and still am. I'm only keeping for the accessories and the thought of getting the heads redone.
I've had an overall positive impression of Superman and have said as much in my review despite having to scrub that paint off the eyeballs along with a few other things that aren't great on it.
Just b/c you're more forgiving of the QC issues that some of us have experienced, doesn't make them any less valid of a reason(s) for being disappointed with what we're receiving when they occur.
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2009
- Messages
- 9,893
- Reaction score
- 3,135
Yes this is correct and thank you for the shout out. 2DOUBLE8IGHT run has 3 spots remaining and then I will close the run.
While I agree with that, I also think the price that InArt are charging set themselves up as the premiere 1/6 figure company and therefore bring out that higher expectation among collectors, myself included.. What I've finding and am adjusting to for my opinion of them are that to me I'm not finding them that much better than HT if at all in some cases; so, I need to lower my expectations which I think helped in my overall impression with BvS Superman. Though, I do like their finer, more human paint apps at least for HP and BvS Sups headsculpts vs the sort of more blanket production paint apps HT tend to do for every human character.
Thanks for asking about it! Sent you a PM with all the info/pics I have
Ha! I think I'm definitely seen as the more unreasonable one when in comes to InArt but that's fine.
Sixth Scale Man
Super Freak
Just got my invoice from Sugo for the standard/sculpted hair. Kinda hoping it would be after Xmas, but oh well. Looking forward to it though.
Price theyāre charging set themselves? So prices that are basically in the same ballpark and either slightly above or in line with Hot Toys pricing, right? Standard sculpted Aragorn was only $335 including tax and overseas shipping costs/fees/etc. Thatās slightly more than a typical Hot Toys SCULPTED figure. Why expect more from INART when theyāre not even that much more than Hot Toys? We can also compare comparable rooted standalone sets if youād like and in some cases, DXAE releases are even more pricey than INART sets, respectively.
You can perceive them how you want all day long, but itās a bit disingenuous imo, at how you/people make it seem, IMO. The price-to-value is much greater with INART than Hot Toys, IMO. But I get it, MMV and we all have different standards and opinions.
Thanks for asking about it! Sent you a PM with all the info/pics I have
Ha! I think I'm definitely seen as the more unreasonable one when in comes to InArt but that's fine.
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2009
- Messages
- 9,893
- Reaction score
- 3,135
While I agree with that, I also think the price that InArt are charging set themselves up as the premiere 1/6 figure company and therefore bring out that higher expectation among collectors, myself included.. What I've finding and am adjusting to for my opinion of them are that to me I'm not finding them that much better than HT if at all in some cases; so, I need to lower my expectations which I think helped in my overall impression with BvS Superman. Though, I do like their finer, more human paint apps at least for HP and BvS Sups headsculpts vs the sort of more blanket production paint apps HT tend to do for every human character.
Thanks for asking about it! Sent you a PM with all the info/pics I have
Ha! I think I'm definitely seen as the more unreasonable one when in comes to InArt but that's fine.
Speaking for myself when Queen Studios announced they were entered 1:6 territory I was excited because I knew the quality Queen was doing with their Busts. And seeing how great their Artist Edition 1:4 Joker was and it being the closest example to 1:6. My expectations soared. The the proto of the 1:6 TDK hit. And I was thinking this will definitely light a fire under HT ass (and it has). But admittingly my excitement and expectations tempered some with the final product. Even though it's still the best 1:6 TDK Joker I have had in hand. I never felt the need to go stupid custom money's on the Joker. It scratched that itch fine enough for me.
But through the 6 InArt figures I have in the collection, I've come to the realization that they are about on the same level as HT just with real hair and a smidgen better scaling and tailoring IMO.
They may not be leaps and bounds better but still a I'd give them the edge...
QC issues aside. And while we will never see a direct comparison with a HT Aragorn or Gandalf because HT refuses to bother themselves with this license, I feel the InArt Joker is still the overall better figure over HT Artisan attempt.
And this is just the begining. If they can iron out the QC issues and tighten up the variations in production for some of these releases (Agagorn) I dont see why they wouldn't/couldn't be "the best". Time will tell on that.
Jumped onboard for one
batsheva
the Duke of Drawing š
Thank you for saying this, I was holding myself from typing the same sentence..I mean really. If InArt Argaorn is Caveman Jesus. Then what on Earth do we call the two Asmus Attempts? Or the ACI? Cave Troll Jesus?
I mean really.
I just don't want to be the sole suspect if something bad happens to Andy.
- Joined
- Sep 13, 2006
- Messages
- 8,763
- Reaction score
- 1,555
Thread has been cleaned up. Please be respectful of people's opinions. You can disagree with an opinion, but let's not call people names or put labels on others over it.
Sassafras
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2016
- Messages
- 8,451
- Reaction score
- 3,238
Well, I was. And I can't say my latest experience will be the same as yours. I was dreading the arrival of #2. Not to mention the shipping was slower, took about 18-20 days.
And I haven't been in this thread, so I don't know what's going on or even if this fig is still for sale. Busy, busy.....
Anyway a completely out of the box pic, thinking "am I going to get *&^% hair again?"
In hand tho, at least first look sculpt and body, no real complaints. After all, I knew what I was getting more or less. This pic isn't the most flattering but this is REALLY out of the box and no time for anything else and the fig is way too cold anyway from being outside.
Or, at least the person who rooted this one IMO was putting their back into it. Trying hard, so thanks to that nameless production line person.
It's good enough of a look that outside of maybe cutting a few bangs (or not) I think I'll just leave it. Plenty of product, the right kind of wave, more or less Amon Hen/Helm's Deep looking e.g. sort of wet-tish. Thankfully longish.Now I just need the Ranger cloaks. LOL now I have a fluffy hair Aragorn and a wet head Aragorn. I can't do anything else until tomorrow and everything warms up.
Good luck to anyone waiting, terrible time for shipping with the holidays etc.
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2009
- Messages
- 9,893
- Reaction score
- 3,135
"Authority is not given to you to deny the return of the king, Steward!"
-Gandalf the White
[The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King 2003]
Got my Caveman Jesus a brand new shiny stick off Aliexpress!
Still warming up to it. Not sure if I like or dislike how shiny it is. But this one is diecast, is scaled better than the Asmus and has the ruins down the blade. Nice cheap alternative.
-Gandalf the White
[The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King 2003]
Got my Caveman Jesus a brand new shiny stick off Aliexpress!
Still warming up to it. Not sure if I like or dislike how shiny it is. But this one is diecast, is scaled better than the Asmus and has the ruins down the blade. Nice cheap alternative.
batsheva
the Duke of Drawing š
That's a shiny and wonderful sword ye got there, CJ!
I donāt think itās disingenuous at all. Most standard HT figures are still below $300. Current standard ones are still anywhere from $250 to about $280 and typically donāt go over unless itās a deluxe, DX, a character HT knows they can milk like Batman, Joker or Iron Man or now Artisan figures. And unless thereās an exclusive or you have to buy direct from SS for some reason, you donāt need to worry about tax, just shipping. Or buying from a local store to which thereās only tax and no shipping. Youāll come out cheaper.
And sure standard Aragorn mightāve been closer to HT pricing, but then you have a more barebones and arguably less complex figure in BvS Superman who costs more than Aragorn. Or standard Ron at $420 which is almost $100 more expensive than standard Harry, who was already more expensive than standard Aragorn. $420 is definitely not in the same ballpark as a current standard HT figure
InArt prices are rising quicker, and quicker even for their standard/sculpted hair figures. If theyāre going to continue to raise their prices even on standard offerings, then collectors are going to expect more from them with each price hike.I agree with most of what you said. I canāt say their (meaning QS) larger statues with rooted hair gave me much confidence seeing how their production pieces seemed to dip quite considerably from the protos, particularly both 1/4 and 1/3 TDK Joker statues since thatās whatās been referenced. But, InArtās TDK Joker proto also excited me to the point I was defending it as much as @HyperDrive defends every InArt release
I definitely agree that if they fix the amount of QC they have (no company is perfect but it can be lessened) and can get the production hair to come closer to the proto, they can definitely get to a point of being arguably the best. I think they also need to get better at their production castings as the amount of detail being lost is a little more than Iād like; BUT, thatās a problem HT has had for a long time and is only relatively recently getting better at.
I think your realization is the same one Iāve come to now with Superman in hand. I know for myself, I expected a bit closer to custom quality (like the clothing for instance) rather than the bit better than HT. Now that I donāt really have that expectation anymore, going forward, Iād like to think Iāll have a better experience with my future orders (as long as theyāre not riddled with QC issues
)
Last edited:
Similar threads
