Everyone's entitled to their own tastes, but I agree that AVPR had more to enjoy. There was nothing other than the hand-to-hand Pred-Alien fight and the Scar-Queen fight that stands out as highlights from AVP. It wasn't anything special. With AVPR, I enjoyed the score, the camera work for the most part, creature design and effects, and the Wolf Pred's character. Sadly those nice elements were swirled in amidst a sea of crap, but the ammount of run time in the film that they occupied is far higher than the high points of AVP for me. I still watch AVP, but of the 2 AVP films, I'll elect to watch AVPR more often.
I respect all your opinions of course
but allow me to explain in detail as for WHY I prefer avp MUCH MORE than avp:r thru simple rules of filmmaking:
Imagery, this is very essential in this kind of movie! Problem here with AvP:R you just could not see the action. When falling a sleep in front off it, you would just be missing the same as watching it, because the cinematography was just plain bad, I hope you guys also agree with that? otherwise I do not understand if you guys call yoursef Alien (or Predator) fan. The original movies where the reference in terms of bringing supence to the screen...
Here there was no suspence, no nothing.
Did you guys see the same movie?
Because it flaws were quite obvious...
Even when you look at the director of photography you can see he has no experience what so ever in making a movie...just music-videoclips
https://imdb.com/name/nm0669050/
and then all of a sudden he is dropped into this action-franchise...hmm
and this comment on imdb is a good reflection of what the film really is:
"
Alien vs. Predator: Requiem is a franchise-killer. It's not even good enough to be as bad as a straight-to-video teen slasher such as, "I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer." To those just looking for some fun action and gore -- look somewhere else. Most of the kills in AVP:R are ultra-fast or off-screen. A few tiny snips and the film could have been a PG-13.
Even Paul Anderson's PG-13 AVP abomination left 2 of the greatest monsters in sci-fi history with a little bit of dignity intact. The Brothers Strause, with their inability to properly stage or direct an action or suspense scene, have made both creatures look like B-grade monsters that should be hidden in a Black Lagoon somewhere.
The Aliens aren't kept in the dark to create a mood -- they're kept there to hide their low-budget appearance and their director's inability to direct. The Predator walks around like a WWE wrestler, grunting at everyone and using blue ooze to melt victims in an attempt to cover his tracks (but, at the same time, he skins other people alive and leaves them hanging from trees).
Next time the Predator race decide to send only 1 of their peeps to represent, they may want to reconsider sending the mentally handicapped guy in the bunch. Or was this the Alien and Predator's version of the Special Olympics? As for the humans? Who cares? Obviously not the filmmakers. There's no believable human character to follow, identify or empathize with. It's just some 25 year old actors playing teenagers with a few older characters thrown in to attract the adult demographic who watched Alien and Predator movies when they were still good.
The best thing anyone could get out of Alien vs. Predator: Requiem is a refund. If you have any respect left for either of these franchises or simply value your free time stay far, far away from this movie. Hopefully the Strause brothers will stay just as far away from a camera, before taking it upon themselves to defecate all over another beloved film franchise."
and okay, avp may be bad, but at least it was enjoyable...
the camerawork and the effects were great! you could actually see what happend in a professional way!
I would only give avp:r a chance if they would reshoot the darn thing, because at least 50% of the whole experience got lost, just because of bad photograpy (and lighting
)
and actually also the human characters, I cannot help myself but feeling annoyed by them, the only things they could say in the movie was ****, ****, ******, scream,...they could have done a whole lot better there too.
As for the R-rating??? becaus it was so badly captured, you couldn't even notice you were looking at an R-rated movie! (execpt from the scene where the predalien shuved something in the pregnant woman's neck
)
By far avp was better on the technical side ánd on the story-side (wich was by itself not so good either when compared to the original movies of course)
The sad thing is that the first movie had more redeeming qualities than this waste!
I was, from the bottom of my alien-franchise fan-heart, disgussed by this movie...