None of that is new or groundbreaking for a summer film...it's not even new for WB. The Nolan Batman already did that in 2005, 2008, and 2012...same time period the Marvel films were coming out. But even Marvel made The Winter Soldier and Fox made First Class and DOFP.
I am not saying they are right

It's just what they saw the film as. They feel Snyder did not play it safe like a Marvel Comic film might. Thus making it edgy and more "artistic". I don't agree. I liked BvS but it was far from special and unless the R Rated cut really improves the film I don't think it will be remembered as a classic.
Batman v Superman was great. Not sure why everyone's having an epic meltdown about it. Saw it three times, and that'll do until the director's cut comes out. As is the case with any movie, it suffered from some problematic issues, but nothing that didn't also plague EVERY OTHER COMIC BOOK MOVIE EVER. Also Force Awakens (another great movie.) Watched that the other night and wondered why it's totally okay for Poe and Finn to be super BFFs after a couple of minutes in a TIE Fighter, yet people are whining about the 'Martha' scene from BvS? What a joke. Nerds are so funny.
I thought it had a lot more issues then say BB, TDK, IM, TIH (I am biased

), The Avengers, GotG (not a huge fan though) and CA:TWS.
I would say it's more 2nd tier. More in the vein of the Thor films, TDKR, Ant-man, and CA:TFA
But it's better the IM 2 and 3, MOS, and Avengers: AOU
Now before people freak about how a placed in the second tier.. It may very well stand at the top of that heap. But it suffers from many of the issues that these films do. It suffers from more problems then the top tier film. The first tier while not all perfect films seemed to get it right as far as Comic movies go with both action, story, and how well they get the characters they are about.
As for TFA BFF scene... Finn did just rescue Poe and Poe did just Help Finn escape.. That BFF makes more sense then... "Hey are mom's have the same name.. Forget that I was just about to kill you"
BTW I had no issues with the Martha moment
