Captain America: The First Avenger Discussion Thread

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I think this was a perfect rendition of Captain America. I'm warning you now this may get a little melodramatic.
When I was a kid I was allergic to pretty much every thing. I had two much larger and much more athletically gifted brothers and my eyesight was horrible. I grew up spending most of my time with my toys, and comic books. Back in the 70's there wasn't a lot in the way of entertainment by today's standards; no vcrs, computers, video games and only 6 channels on the TV. We had a place that sold half cover comics for 9/$1, stacked on tables that you had to fa through to find what you wanted. I collected Captain America, X-Men, Fantastic Four and Spider-Man, my brother collected Thor, Iron Man, Avengers, and Conan. Captain America became my favorite and from reading the reprints of his WWII adventures, it got me interested in the war that my father fought in. I would sit with him watching WWII shows on PBS, and although he rarely spoke of anything about the war, sometimes he would share a bit. Since both of mine were much older than most of the other parents I grew up in an environment that was less emotionally demonstrative than we see today. People were more conscious of maintaining a little class, no Jerry Springer guests around.
We had a large collection of Mego superheroes, but Captain America was always elusive, but one day, my dad took me to a store and we finally found my Cap figure, although I was just about too old to play with it.
Back then, we had the cheesy Spider-Man show, the crappy Captain America movies and the enjoyable Hulk series, but VCRs, DVD players, computers and such were a ways off yet. Each time someone tried to bring a superhero to life it was usually instant fail. We got used to accepting anything that wasn't horrible and even swallowing some that was, just to get our fix. Marvel fans would look at Superman and wonder why we couldn't get a decent film made.
As time went on, I got healthier, lifted weights and learned martial arts, but Captain America always stuck with me. When I heard this was being made, I prayed it would be decent. I tried not to get too wrapped up in a lot of the negative sentiment, but I prepared myself for a let down.
Today as I walked into the theater with my son, who was aware of my high hopes, I couldn't help thinking of going to movies with my own father. As the film started, the way the characters spoke had a distinct depression era quality of which I was familiar. The street scenes looked so much like the photos I had looked at all my life. As the film went on I found myself enjoying this to a level I didn't think possible.
Being so familiar with the comics, I saw the adjustments made to the film media but felt everything was done with extreme care and loyalty to the original source. I felt the action was superb, the pacing was great, and I felt it was very emotional. People back then didn't just come right out with their feelings, there was a lot under the surface, a lot that simmered.
Watching Steve Rogers and his transformation and then really getting a feel of just how much he lost, was very powerful.
When we started seeing Marvel films being made, I got optimistic, but this exceeded my greatest expectations. I may be biased, but I think its a solid 10.
 
Cap was awesome. Saw it Sunday with some of the sideshow folks and had a great time. Will be seeing this again at least two more times.
 
Cap was awesome. Saw it Sunday with some of the sideshow folks and had a great time. Will be seeing this again at least two more times.

I've seen it twice and plan on seeing again! :D

Harry Potter will own this summer.

128748701162345058.jpg
 
Can anyone let me know if it's worth going to see this in 3D or 2D? I'm not a fan of post converted films, just interested to hear what is the best version to see.

thanks!
 
From Bad Ass Digest:

https://www.badassdigest.com/2011/07/25/why-the-ending-of-captain-america-kind-of-sucks

I really liked Captain America: The First Avenger (my review here), but I have to be the first to admit that the ending sucks. It isn’t that the scenes are bad on their own; I like the idea of SHIELD trying to keep a newly unfrozen Cap calm by pretending it’s the 1940s (although how dumb are they to broadcast a baseball game from about FOUR YEARS before he froze?), and I liked the last line in a conceptual way. I just hate it as the ending of this movie.

I hate it because this movie had a great ending – the kids playing in the street with the homemade Captain America shield. It was a perfect final image, showing that Cap lived up to his greatest role, being a symbol of hope. It’s a great image. And then it cuts to the modern day stuff, which undermines that wonderful shot.

What’s worse, there’s not a single moment in the film explaining what the hell the ending is about. There’s the opening scene, where the Skull’s crashed bomber is found, but no comparable scene where we understand that Steve Rogers survived the crash and was frozen in ice. Hell, if I didn’t know the story I might have assumed Nick Fury had Steve Rogers cloned or something. It’s really poorly handled, and it doesn’t feel like it belongs at the end of this movie at all.

That’s because it doesn’t! I’ve heard multiple rumors – none that I can confirm* – that the Times Square stuff was intended to go either after the credits or during them, after the first round of animated credits. It makes more sense there; structurally anything placed after the credits roll is an extra or a teaser, and isn’t impacting the main film itself. But when placed in the main body of the film the scene is suddenly jarring and weird and obviously doesn’t fit.

It’s ironic that the worst part of the movie is the Avengers wanking bit, as that has been what sank Thor and Iron Man 2. Captain America was, like Iron Man, a movie allowed to live on its own terms, without bowing to restrictive continuity demands. Even the presence of Howard Stark feels organic and unforced. But it’s that last scene which gives us a kick in the nuts as we leave the theater.

I wish that Marvel had kept that coda in the credits, where it belongs. Next time I watch Captain America, which will probably be on Blu, I’ll be sure to stop the film right when those kids are playing in the street.

* Joe Johnston has said that he didn’t direct the post-credits Nick Fury/Steve Rogers scene, but what he means is that he didn’t direct the Steve-in-the-boxing-ring scene at the beginning of The Avengers teaser.
 
Cap brought in 65.8 million opening weekend.
Harry Potter brought in 169 million its opening weekend.
Potter crushed everything but I still liked Cap better.

I wasn't talking about the box office. I don't care if HP made twice that amount, I'll never see any of it.

Some people said that HP would still be number one on Cap's opening weekend. That didn't happen.

So IMO, HP failed to own the summer. :D
 
Yay, Josh is back :hi5:

Couldn't wait for your review :impatient:

Finally :yess:

Glad to hear you liked it :clap

So, how was SDCC :lol

Yeah, now that I've seen it I'm back in here.

Well, not much of a review but its a great flick. When I see it a second time I'll go through more. I liked it every bit as much as I did Thor. I can't begin to say how much I liked it. Was pretty cool being asked to go with the Sideshow folks as well.

The Con was amazing! I was really busy but will start posting pics and video this week. Lots of good stuff coming.

I've seen it twice and plan on seeing again! :D

Nice!! I'll take Dad to see it and I've got a free movie ticket to see it as well.
 
Cap brought in 65.8 million opening weekend.
Harry Potter brought in 169 million its opening weekend.
Potter crushed everything but I still liked Cap better.

This is not correct HP in it's opening weekend brought in about $47 million Cap
made $65.8 mil.
 
Whats with the HP debate. Clearly Harry potter made more bank but thats becuase harry potter is an awesome franchise. i'm sure the old school superhero fans wont agree but still Harry potter is pretty damn good of course it made more money.
 
Back
Top