Captain America vs Batman

[JBElliott]

 

[Wulf]

 

[JBElliott]

 

[JBElliott]

 

[Wulf]

 

[steve74]

Haha I wonder how many times Superman has done this then does his time travel trick just so he can do it again?

 

[Alex Logan]

I'm sort of glad I don't know everything there is to know about these two characters. It looks like people that have all this sort of "knowledge" are douchey.

Thanks buddy, I appreciate that.

 

[thenammagazine]

There's your moral compass, Kara.

 

[Alex Logan]

Disagreeing with my ideas about how this fight would go down is fine, but atleast back it up with some real comic book knowledge. I've yet to see a single person do that up to this point.

Just because you like one character more then the other doesn't mean you know jack about what either one is capable of doing. Go read a few really good stories about both guys and then come back to the debate.

 

[Uncanny Web-Slinger]

so full of epic win!!!!!

 

[thenammagazine]

Disagreeing with my ideas about how this fight would go down is fine, but atleast back it up with some real comic book knowledge. I've yet to see a single person do that up to this point.

Just because you like one character more then the other doesn't mean you know jack about what either one is capable of doing. Go read a few really good stories about both guys and then come back to the debate.

For such a braggart (based on your post in the Hulk vs. Superman thread and statements made here), you should be well familiar with both, and thusly understand that Cap is essentially Batman without the bank roll and a slightly lower intellect, but vastly superior strength, stamina and agility.

 

[Darth Snoopy]

​

 

[Alex Logan]

For such a braggart (based on your post in the Hulk vs. Superman thread and statements made here), you should be well familiar with both, and thusly understand that Cap is essentially Batman without the bank roll and a slightly lower intellect, but vastly superior strength, stamina and agility.

I am familiar with both and they are nothing alike. If you read comics you would know that both of thier character dynamics run far deeper then the things you just listed.

 

[thenammagazine]

I am familiar with both and they are nothing alike. If you read comics you would know that both of thier character dynamics run far deeper then the things you just listed.

Character "dynamics" =/= stats. But if by dynamics you're referring to undies, I'm gonna go out on a limb and say they both wear blue chonies.

 

[V!cToR]

This is a tough one. I want to go with both but I think Cap would be the winner in the end. Both are superior fighters in the Marvel and DC universes, but I give this one to Captain America. While Batman has the greatest thinking mind, in an all out battle no one tops Cap. He was trained to be a super soldier who could overcome anyone in battle. Cap beat the Nazi's and Adolf Hitler for crying out loud! One man against the guy who decimated the whole WWII Japanese Army, the whole WWII German Army, the North Korean & Red Chinese Armies in the Korean War and regularly slaughtered the militaries of several Communist nations during the 1960s? Batman is a dead man.

As good as Batman is, he really isn't as good a fighter as Captain America. All his extra gadgets wouldn't do much either, if Cap can avoid bullets, he can avoid a simple batarang. DC themselves admitted to this when the first DC/Marvel crossover took place. If you think of this in terms of if this were a real fight, and not on who you like better, then you'd see Cap winning. Batman might win the vote on being more popular, but Captain America could beat him in a fight.

They've both got their smarts and have proven themselves in their strength and abilities but Cap is a step beyond Batman with his physical strength and determination. The man survived being frozen for goodness sake! It basically comes down to this, Captain America is an enhanced human fighting machine due to the super soldier serum. Batman is merely a highly trained schizophrenic. Captain America is the superior hero.

Sorry Bats, love ya, but Cap would win the fight by ramming that sheild up the bat's ____ and twisting it. Patriotism at it's best!

 

[steve74]

I've read many great stories about Batman, watched all the cartoons and movies so I'm pretty well versed in the character. I know more about Batman and am a bigger fan of him than Cap. But I also know how good of a character Cap is and I think you're down playing how effective he is in a fight.
So what in you opinion puts Batman over Cap in a fight? Is it his physical prowess, his fighting knowledge or just his mind?
Because I think physically he is no match for Cap. Their fighting know how are probably a match but that's where the physical skill comes in, better reflex, much faster and way stronger. That stuff does matter in a fight, plus Cap can take more damage and he will kill if he has too. Now the main topic is Batman masterful mind and his tactical skills. Yes his I.Q. is higher but so what? Their not sitting down over a game of chess. Tactically Batman is always "five steps ahead" but that doesn't mean that Caps not tactical genius as well. He out smarted Tony Stark and took him out, he is also the head of SHIELD right now if I'm not mistaken. So I think I have some knowledge of comics and I think I've made so pretty valid points, I await your rebuttal my friend.

 

[teemu]

Batman is cool,but Highly overated! he has no super powers,no super strength

Cap is a Super Soldier,given super strength!

Cap all the way!

 

[peedi]

This is a tough one. I want to go with both but I think Cap would be the winner in the end. Both are superior fighters in the Marvel and DC universes, but I give this one to Captain America. While Batman has the greatest thinking mind, in an all out battle no one tops Cap. He was trained to be a super soldier who could overcome anyone in battle. Cap beat the Nazi's and Adolf Hitler for crying out loud!

As good as Batman is, he really isn't as good a fighter as Captain America. All his extra gadgets wouldn't do much either, if Cap can avoid bullets, he can avoid a simple batarang. DC themselves admitted to this when the first DC/Marvel crossover took place. If you think of this in terms of if this were a real fight, and not on who you like better, then you'd see Cap winning. Batman might win the vote on being more popular, but Captain America could beat him in a fight.

They've both got their smarts and have proven themselves in their strength and abilities but Cap is a step beyond Batman with his physical strength and determination. The man survived being frozen for goodness sake! It basically comes down to this, Captain America is an enhanced human fighting machine due to the super soldier serum. Batman is merely a highly trained schizophrenic. Captain America is the superior hero.

Sorry Bats, love ya, but Cap would win the fight by ramming that sheild up the bat's ____ and twisting it. Patriotism at it's best!

The parts in bold, you nailed it for any of these types of debates for any character.

Most people will:

1. Pick their favorite then justify by any means why that character would win. Or:

2. Pick the character they personally know better. Because somehow not knowing a character as well means they should lose. Or:

3. Pick the overall more popular character regardless of that making little sense.

There are people who are well versed on both charaters, but these disputes will always end up just being popularity contests. Plus, 1 fight proves nothing.

 

[Ryanfromindiana]

Batman is cool,but Highly overated! he has no super powers,no super strength.

That's what like almost everyone about to face Batman says in the comics right before he smashes their faces in.

 

[karamazov80]

There's your moral compass, Kara.

Yeah Well, if it was Chris Reeve Superman from Superman 2, he might really do it. He was an apparent wanton murderer, he erased memories, he beat up human bullies for revenge, etc. I wouldn't ____ with that Superman.