Captain America vs Batman

[Frankenstein1]

Cap would win the first encounter because of strength. Batman would go back to the Bat Cave and come up with someway to cheat his way to win the next time.

 

[NASEDO]

If Batman wins on Brains then Stephen Hawking beats them all.

 

[isculpt]

If Batman wins on Brains then Stephen Hawking beats them all.

Lol so Iron Man, Mr. Fantastic, and Ant-Man should all be able to best Batman like it's nothing.

 

[Shai]

Squirrel Girl would kick their ***** pretty easily.

 

[Uncanny Web-Slinger]

I voted for Cap, cos this is the Marvel section

 

[badrat]

 

[BrooklynWolf X]

I don't buy this "5 steps ahead" bs. Ok the 2 are going to fight so we'll let Batman have the time plan the fight out so he can learn everything he needs to know about Cap in order for Batman to win. While this is happening we'll let Cap sit there with his thumb up his butt wondering what's keeping Batman?
Yes Batman is the man with the plan but you don't think Cap can come up with a plan as well (given the time)? Batman is able to take out Metas or Supers because most of the time he knows what he's dealing with and yes I know he can think on his feet becasue of his training, mind set and drive. So can Cap, he taken out whole Shield teams. Also just because Cap was around is the 40s when many of the fighting arts were unknown to the western world doesn't mean he hasn't master them now. Marvel Encyclopedia has him ranked as one of the top fighters in the Marvel U, just like Bats "master" of all forms of fighting. I love Bats just as much as the next guy but some of you are crazy to underscore Cap, the guys a real badass. And as faster and strong as Batman is Cap is a least 4X that. So think about how strong or fast you are, then think about getting hit in the face 4X that. Cap comes out on top.

I voted 'draw', as I stated before, i am a huge batman fan, yet I can't bring myself to choose one over the other. However, I have to dispute what you said right there. Sure some here are underestimating caps prowess, but aren't you doing the same with bats? I agree that if bat took a punch from cap, he's gonna feel it...thats IF caps can even touch the bat. Yea, cap's power and speed are above bats, but Batman has gone against superhumans that don't have a weakness like superman and won...that's without planning too! Thats what some here keep insisting, that in order for batman to come out victorious, he needs his 'plan time', as if it's the equivalent to Voltron's sword, that once the sword comes out, it's over. Batman has many a time taken out meta humans without his win button known as 'plan time'.

Both are warriors that are quick on their feet, always thinking 5 steps ahead. Like someone here said, bats will win one, caps will win one. Its hard to decide who will ultimately come out victorious.

 

[thenammagazine]

LOL

I don't recall saying anything about hand-to-hand. Just like Batman, Castle would realize he's outclassed and use any means necessary to get the win, which like Batman, includes cheating. So snipe to the open face, FTFW!

 

[Darth Snoopy]

It's because of this type of nerd fights, we banned certain fanboys from loitering in the comic shop I used to work at.

 

[steve74]

I voted 'draw', as I stated before, i am a huge batman fan, yet I can't bring myself to choose one over the other. However, I have to dispute what you said right there. Sure some here are underestimating caps prowess, but aren't you doing the same with bats? I agree that if bat took a punch from cap, he's gonna feel it...thats IF caps can even touch the bat. Yea, cap's power and speed are above bats, but Batman has gone against superhumans that don't have a weakness like superman and won...that's without planning too! Thats what some here keep insisting, that in order for batman to come out victorious, he needs his 'plan time', as if it's the equivalent to Voltron's sword, that once the sword comes out, it's over. Batman has many a time taken out meta humans without his win button known as 'plan time'.

Both are warriors that are quick on their feet, always thinking 5 steps ahead. Like someone here said, bats will win one, caps will win one. Its hard to decide who will ultimately come out victorious.

I do agree with you on some points but in the long run I think Cap could take him, I'm saying this as a bigger Batman fan than Cap but I think too many people down play how much of a badass Cap really is.

 

[thenammagazine]

It's because of this type of nerd fights, we banned certain fanboys from loitering in the comic shop I used to work at.

So they didn't let you come in anymore when you were off the clock, huh?

 

[Alex Logan]

And Batman shot him!

Cheater!

Not the fight I was referring too.

I don't buy this "5 steps ahead" bs. Ok the 2 are going to fight so we'll let Batman have the time plan the fight out so he can learn everything he needs to know about Cap in order for Batman to win. While this is happening we'll let Cap sit there with his thumb up his butt wondering what's keeping Batman?

Yes Batman is the man with the plan but you don't think Cap can come up with a plan as well (given the time)? Batman is able to take out Metas or Supers because most of the time he knows what he's dealing with and yes I know he can think on his feet becasue of his training, mind set and drive. So can Cap, he taken out whole Shield teams. Also just because Cap was around is the 40s when many of the fighting arts were unknown to the western world doesn't mean he hasn't master them now. Marvel Encyclopedia has him ranked as one of the top fighters in the Marvel U, just like Bats "master" of all forms of fighting. I love Bats just as much as the next guy but some of you are crazy to underscore Cap, the guys a real badass. And as faster and strong as Batman is Cap is a least 4X that. So think about how strong or fast you are, then think about getting hit in the face 4X that. Cap comes out on top.

Whenever I read something like this about Batman I just have to laugh. Batman doesn't NEED to plan ahead or to KNOW his enemy to win a fight. There are many cases where he found his opponents weakness during battle. A prefect example is the White Martian storyline from JLA. The White Martians, a race of shapeshifters come to earth posing as heroes. After making the JLA look bad they defeat and capture every member except Batman. Batman figures out who they are and uses their weakness to save the whole team.

Cap wins 100% of the time, no question. DC is like pee-wee football compared to the NFL level of Marvel.

This is joke right? Guess you've never read any DC books.

I feel alot of the times, Batman just lucks out. Thats what I like about Capt, he is still susceptible to defeat, even at his best. I understand Batman is a genius, yadda, yadda, yadda, but I feel his "power" relies too much on deus ex machinas that come out nowhere sometimes. Capt has a shield, most of the time it works, sometimes it doesn't. (Fear Itself, Infinity Gauntlet, etc)

Luck has nothing to do with it. If you think Batman relies too much machines I had have to guess that you haven't read very many Batman comics.

Cap would win the first encounter because of strength. Batman would go back to the Bat Cave and come up with someway to cheat his way to win the next time.

Say hello to Frankenstein1 the Marvel Fanboy. Glad you could join us.

 

[thenammagazine]

Whenever I read something like this about Batman I just have to laugh. Batman doesn't NEED to plan ahead or to KNOW his enemy to win a fight. There are many cases where he found his opponents weakness during battle. A prefect example is the White Martian storyline from JLA. The White Martians, a race of shapeshifters come to earth posing as heroes. After making the JLA look bad they defeat and capture every member except Batman. Batman figures out who they are and uses their weakness to save the whole team.

So he didn't once visit the Batcave, the Batmobile or put a call in to Alfred during that whole story arc?

 

[isculpt]

LOL, Batman vs. threads are just not fun. Lemme guess, he can beat Thor, Captain America, Hulk, Galactus, Galactus's Heralds, Scarlet Witch, the Phoenix Force, The Void/Sentry, Molecule Man, Thanos with Infinity Gauntlet, The Living Tribunal, The One Above All, the artist drawing Batman in the comic he is appearing in, the wringing authoring his fights, the colorist who colors him, and even the customer who buys his comic....

 

[isculpt]

Sorry, did I miss anyone?

 

[Fisherprice]

Actually Batman would have thrown the Batarangs as a distraction and knowing that he is outmatched physically he would have used his superior intellect as well as his superior martial arts skills to kick cap's arse. Now I'm a marvel guy but Cap is just walking inspiration. Other than him dying I really don't see him doing anything special. He was a major let down during the Civil War. He never really tackles the heavies of his universe one on one.
Where as we have seen Batman go toe to toe or outwit some of the biggest guns in DC.
The real question we should be asking is who would win

Batman or ULTIMATE CAPTAIN AMERICA.

 

[steve74]

So he didn't once visit the Batcave, the Batmobile or put a call in to Alfred during that whole story arc?

I was thinking the same thing, since when do fights last long enough for someone to run away regroup and figure out what to do then come back for the win? This is a fight between two people that's it, not some battlefield war or a fight with 3-5 minute rounds. I know alittle something about fighting and most of them are over with in minutes if not seconds. I think everyone knows if Batman had the time he would find a way to beat Cap but I'm not talking about that.

 

[Avenger]

Thought about a draw on this, but went Batman. Batman knows how to think outside the box, and strategize. Cap, muscles in and goes for the direct approach. I think Batman would out fox him.

 

[xYx]

This really isn't even a contest. Bane beat Batman and Cap would hand Bane his ass on a silver tray.

If you're talking about "Knightfall", Bane released the inmates of Arkham on Batman & waited for him to be physically & mentally exhausted before going in for the kill.

 

[thenammagazine]

If you're talking about "Knightfall", Bane released the inmates of Arkham on Batman & waited for him to be physically & mentally exhausted before going in for the kill.

Bane lacks the stamina and agility of Cap. Cap would be that whole fight rolled into a single man with better fighting skills than Bane and definitely smarter/more experienced.