Entropy Chicken asks
Just curious for those who didn't like the film, what would have made it better? Less shakey camera - check. more revealing info about the monster - check. what else??
I would not have changed a thing. A filmmaker has the right to make a movie which puts their own vision upon the screen. That is what happened here. From this thread response, it is obvious that a certain sector of the film going public responded to it very positively. A 41 million dollar opening weekend also shows it was well received, at least by a sector of the public.
I do agree with a previous observation by Dusty that the money will be good for a week or two and then fall off quickly. I would also add that a gimmick film like this is just the kind of movie in a year or two to get a reaction of "I wonder why we were so excited about that?".
I did not like this as a big screen film for all the reasons that I previously mentioned. Perhaps it would have worked as a stand alone TV movie if you could cut at least half of the first 20 minutes in that apartment with those vapid people.
I hae been thinking about why I so loathed the people involved and did not care one bit about them or what happened to them. Its not age, because HEROES - which I like quite a bit - is also a young cast and I do care about them. Its not the approach because I like LOST a great deal. Its not their glitzy, meaningless existence revolving around parties and bling, because that means little to me either way. They are, after all, just cardboard characters on a screen. I blame this on the filmmakers because they gave me no reason to care about these people.
As far as horor or suspense, I found nothing in this film remotely scary or suspensful. Not one second.
I wonder how much it would have cost to make the same movie but without the handheld camera gimmick? Three times the budget? Four? I think that tells you why they filmed it like they did?
They made people think they were getting the latest in cutting edge technique when actually they found a way to give you less for your money.