Ewan does a Sir Alec impression

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I agree. ROTS is the best. So it doesn't have Han. It is the pillar for which the entire saga rests upon. It is the most dramatic and tragic. ROTS was everything I could have hoped for. Flawless? Hardly. But it delivered on so many levels.

ROTS also delivered a masterly performance from Ian McDiarmid as Palpatine. Ian was my favorite thing about the prequel trilogy, and in ROTS he pretty much stole the show.

Ewan's performances were also a highlight. His impersonation of Sir Alec's mannerisms were at time uncanny.

I've thought a lot about it, and I've come to the conclusion that Hayden was not the best choice to play Anakin. A better actor could have played up the nuances of Anakin's egomaniacal side that ultimately destroyed him.

I also could have done without Padme's "dying from a broken heart" bit. In my mind, Anakin murdered her, making the tragedy of Vader sufficiently ironic.
 
Everyone loves to misinterpret the whole "Alex hated Star Wars" thing.

I think you mean "Alec."

Did you hear about the kid who asked Guiness for his autograph and told him he'd seen Star Wars over 100 times and Sir "Alec" would only agree to sign it if the kid promised him he would never watch Star Wars again? Yup, true story. And Sir "Alec" has said on more than one occasion that he thought the Star Wars films were "complete and utter rubbish."

Actors do a job to get paid. 90% of the scripts they get handed are garbage and often they take the work when they can get it. Unless you are as big as Harrison Ford and have the power to pass on most of those scripts but judging from Ford's career the last 10 years he's done just as many duds as McGregor has.
 
I was just thinking about that as I was reading your post... now that [The Island] is a movie to be ashamed of.

Ewan got to spend a month or two with Scarlett Johannsen. Not hard to find the bright side of that experience.

I won't believe this quote until I hear it from a reputable source.

By the way, "Star Wars" wasn't a movie that Ewan McGregor appeared in. However, I wouldn't be shocked if he named one of the first two movies as "the one film he liked least".

Someone mentioned above that Ewan would've become just as famous without appearing in the prequels. I don't necessarily agree. I love him as an actor, but that's only after tracking down so many of his other appearances, something I never would've done if I hadn't been exposed to him through the PT .
 
I think you mean "Alec."

Did you hear about the kid who asked Guiness for his autograph and told him he'd seen Star Wars over 100 times and Sir "Alec" would only agree to sign it if the kid promised him he would never watch Star Wars again? Yup, true story. And Sir "Alec" has said on more than one occasion that he thought the Star Wars films were "complete and utter rubbish."

Actors do a job to get paid. 90% of the scripts they get handed are garbage and often they take the work when they can get it. Unless you are as big as Harrison Ford and have the power to pass on most of those scripts but judging from Ford's career the last 10 years he's done just as many duds as McGregor has.


As I understand it Alec was a man of faith (Catholic to be exact) who only agreed to do A New Hope because of the decided Christian undertones. Then Empire came out which revealed George's Buddhist's take on the Force. Suddenly not only was Alec's career being eclipsed by his supporting role but now the wholesome Christian children's movie he decided to do is Unitarian at best and new age Eastern at worst. Followers of both, the Pope just reminded people, are all going to burn in Hell.
 
I think you mean "Alec."

Did you hear about the kid who asked Guiness for his autograph and told him he'd seen Star Wars over 100 times and Sir "Alec" would only agree to sign it if the kid promised him he would never watch Star Wars again? Yup, true story. And Sir "Alec" has said on more than one occasion that he thought the Star Wars films were "complete and utter rubbish."

Actors do a job to get paid. 90% of the scripts they get handed are garbage and often they take the work when they can get it. Unless you are as big as Harrison Ford and have the power to pass on most of those scripts but judging from Ford's career the last 10 years he's done just as many duds as McGregor has.

Yes, "Dave" I heard that story. I also heard the one about Richard Gear and a gerbel and that one about you in a Minneapolis airport bathroom. :)D Yeah, I know it's Gere ... was going to see how many quotation marks you would use before you got bored, but then I got bored with it.) However, I tend to take them for what they are ... stories. Much like the supposed Ewan interview. I am always amazed at how we (and I mean the whole forum culture that thrives today) argue with each other and demand proof of everything. However, the minute some second hand hearsay is printed, we accept it for fact. Could the story be true? Sure. But, as someone else pointed out, until Ewan issues the words officially, I am going to classify it all as rumor.

But let's assume the Guinness story is true. You never told someone who was irritating you something out of anger? I love Star Wars, but would probably still make a smirky comment if someone was bragging about watching the film 100 times ... and that was supposedly back in the early 90s.

As for "doing a job to get paid", that's what modern actors do ... much like modern athletes. Anything for a buck, screw the strength of the work. And, I am sure there were some old school actors who did the same thing. But people like Guiness didn't just take a role to make a house payment. In 1977, he was both financial well-off and a name actor (Lucas himself has said that Guinness and Cushing were the "matinee" names that gave the producers enough confidence to accept a largely unknown cast). https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000027/ Take a look at his movie history. I don't see many "paycheck" movies listed there. Don't assume that just because most of the people have no work/ personal ethic, that Sir Guinness didn't. I wish I could find the interview. But, on at least one occasion, he told an interviewer that he didn't like the life that Star Wars had taken on. How he had agreed to do the script because it was interesting and unique. Don't believe if you don't want to. That's your right.

P.S. As for Ford making as many duds, that doesn't mean he made all those movies just for the money. Many big name actors have strange "what the heck were they thinking" roles listed in their resume. We are so quick to assume it was for a big paycheck. But, who's to say they didn't like the script or subject matter? Having a name and plenty of money gives you a lot more freedom. You don't have to worry about bad reviews because the public loves you and you are financially well off enough to survive any fallout.
 
I agree. ROTS is the best. So it doesn't have Han. It is the pillar for which the entire saga rests upon. It is the most dramatic and tragic. ROTS was everything I could have hoped for. Flawless? Hardly. But it delivered on so many levels.

I agree with that completely. I also agree with MaulFan that there was no way George could have created something that would live up to the hype and the excitement people had when he first announced he would do the PT.
 
I think you mean "Alec."

Did you hear about the kid who asked Guiness for his autograph and told him he'd seen Star Wars over 100 times and Sir "Alec" would only agree to sign it if the kid promised him he would never watch Star Wars again? Yup, true story. And Sir "Alec" has said on more than one occasion that he thought the Star Wars films were "complete and utter rubbish."

Actors do a job to get paid. 90% of the scripts they get handed are garbage and often they take the work when they can get it. Unless you are as big as Harrison Ford and have the power to pass on most of those scripts but judging from Ford's career the last 10 years he's done just as many duds as McGregor has.

P.S. Dave, the first post was never meant as a personal attack. I have heard many people express the same opinion. I was just voicing my own on the subject based upon the information I have seen.
 
Umm -- not sure if someone mentioned this before as I have not read the whole thread, but this has been around since AOTC and Ewan set the record straight when he said he hated the blue/green screen work as its boring ( or something along those lines, so no big suprises there that SW was his least favourite films to be involved with... plus you ad on top of that every SW nerd greeting him with may the force be with you.... for the rest of your life and you'd have regrets too...:rotfl
 
Back
Top