The show will almost certainly still be running and broadcasting by November 2024.
We are all still in a world wide pandemic. There have been a lot of casualties, scandals, controversy and division over all kinds of issues stemming from it. I can see HBO erroring on the side of caution here. There are certain storylines and certain themes they want to avoid, i.e. to not alienate some large segment of their potential audience.
The majority of Hollywood, at least those outspoken, lean in one specific direction. Making TLOU1 in line with the game doesn't help their cause or desired outcomes. It just doesn't.
I also believe HBO is looking at The Mandalorian and off camera controversies there. Including some with Pedro Pascal. His role in Wonder Woman 1984 was also polarizing to a large potential segment of the general viewing audience.
Everything offends everyone nearly all the time now. HBO wants lots of viewers and to make lots of money. They have to toe a certain line with themes and plotlines that push a little too close to real life.
What HBO does not want is TLOU turning into a referendum on what has happened in the past four years, particularly the last two, that every day Americans just can't avoid.
Look at how I'm threading the needle here. Because even skirting the issue, even if it's relevant to the show, I still am bracing myself and am expected to be attacked by someone. We have been conditioned to expected to be gaslit, canceled, shamed and attacked all the time now. It's the new normal. It's why HBO would rather take the tone of TLOU and make it as vanilla as possible. Someone, somewhere, is going to pissed out of their mind about something, and it's going to cost them money.
Put yourself as an executive anywhere right now in film and TV production. Could be HBO, could be AMC, could be Paramount, could be anything. If you say the wrong thing, just once, even if you say something that would normally have been seen as innocuous maybe 10 years ago, now you have to think about people digging in your entire life. Seeing if you said something in a high school term paper back in 1984 that could get your career set on fire today.
Could HBO make The Sopranos today? Sex And The City? The Wire?
I finished episode 7 last night. At some level, I can't blame HBO and Craig Mazin for toeing a certain line. At the end of the day, they just want to put food on the table for their kids like everyone else.
The toned down elements of TLOU is a lagging indictor of a larger complex issue within the entire industry but also reflecting on the way things are being treated and handled in our entire modern culture. I agree with anyone here who says, "Just tell a damn good story and focus on telling the best story possible above all else" I wholeheartedly agree with that. But it's not what we have now. TLOU is tailored to not offend those who are offended by everything. If that sounds pretty stupid, well, it is pretty stupid. What has happened to modern entertainment is the byproduct of lots of stupid people having a very large immediate platform.