Jrobertson
Super Freak
TWD is just so repetitive and boring I quit watching a couple seasons ago.
HBO's Game of Thrones
- Thread starter Batty
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
That was the only reason I used it as a comparison, got is light years above twd
ending of this weeks episode was satisfying....what a beyotch
devilof76
Super Freak
Considering the caliber of writers crafting the source material for the two shows, it should be expected that the difference in quality of the stories being put to film will be reflected in the quality of the shows. Martin is a novelist; Kirkman writes comics. One group of producers has a lot more to work with than the other.
Sidewinder
Super Freak
Well I watch both and enjoy them both. They're really very different shows, so i can't really compare them because they're not even the same genre. If it were comparing two superhero shows against each other, then yes, I can make that comparison.
I enjoy both these shows for what they are.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I enjoy both these shows for what they are.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Something Sexy
Super Freak
Both shows are great but guess what GoT only fans, the quality of this show is dropping as the seasons go on. Although not entirely D&D fault since the books peaked at 3.
rushmore223
Super Freak
Most stories tend to drag a bit in the middle, which is where we are now. Still GOT at its worst is better than jut about everything else currently on TV.
not sure i agree with that....
Mr. Green
Super Freak
finished season1 and gonna be done with season2 soon. man this show is definitely better than TWD but both have its appeal. can it even be properly compared? things that make you go hmmmm. the storyline and nudity is awesome for sure.
quality dropping? lol
Last edited:
Invictus Sol
No Life in the Void
Haven't noticed any drop in quality in either the books or show, so that's entirely subjective.
Not directed at you, specifically, but TWD fans sure are defensive. I kinda regretted making that comment after I posted because I knew it'd invite a bunch of apologist comments on behalf of the show. I watch and enjoy it, too, but nothing wrong with calling it like it is, folks! Anyway, lets start fresh with tonight's episode and leave all WD talk behind us!
Deckard
Super Freak
A Jedi Warrior
Super Freak
such an Awesome episode the best of this season and maybe my favorite of any season! 
- Joined
- Sep 23, 2008
- Messages
- 12,907
- Reaction score
- 2,115
such an Awesome episode the best of this season and maybe my favorite of any season!
Agreed. This has instantly become my most favorite episode, as well. Johnny definitely climbed up a few levels after tonight.
Tonight episode was EPIC!
Quality drop? Man, this episode was amazing. It was movie quality.
devilof76
Super Freak
They're all movie quality.
You **** on something and find a negative response from people who like what you slight to be neurotic? Are you sure it's not neurotic to drag useless comparisons into a thread to praise a show that really doesn't need the knocking down of other shows for its value to be illustrated? Or to expect people to just listen to post after post echoing your derogatory claims, without saying something contrary to your opinion? And where do you get off calling a disagreement with your estimate of Game of Thrones 'subjective', but your verdict on Walking Dead is 'calling it like it is'?
I'm a much bigger fan of this than I am the other, but the last thing I'd do is assume that my tastes were somehow the gold standard of what the rest of the world should prefer.
Haven't noticed any drop in quality in either the books or show, so that's entirely subjective.
Not directed at you, specifically, but TWD fans sure are defensive. I kinda regretted making that comment after I posted because I knew it'd invite a bunch of apologist comments on behalf of the show. I watch and enjoy it, too, but nothing wrong with calling it like it is, folks! Anyway, lets start fresh with tonight's episode and leave all WD talk behind us!
You **** on something and find a negative response from people who like what you slight to be neurotic? Are you sure it's not neurotic to drag useless comparisons into a thread to praise a show that really doesn't need the knocking down of other shows for its value to be illustrated? Or to expect people to just listen to post after post echoing your derogatory claims, without saying something contrary to your opinion? And where do you get off calling a disagreement with your estimate of Game of Thrones 'subjective', but your verdict on Walking Dead is 'calling it like it is'?
I'm a much bigger fan of this than I am the other, but the last thing I'd do is assume that my tastes were somehow the gold standard of what the rest of the world should prefer.
Deckard
Super Freak
Wow. Epic is an understatement.
Similar threads
