Here Is A Geek Thought....

[MaulFan]

Assuming that a force ghost projects an image of themselves as a "whole" being in the force (ie Anakin without his scars, Ben and Yoda at their most powerful as old sages) wouldn't it follow that Luke's force ghost would project the face BEFORE Mark Hamill's face was damaged?

Just a geek thought... I think I may have found a reason to buy another Yavin Luke.... Hmmmmm....

I believe it was stated when Hayden was put into ROTJ that the reason was the Force spirits reflect your final image of good, and Anakin wasn't good long before dying in the Vader suit. Had GL really put effort towards putting Hayden in, he would have had him in full ROTS garbs, but instead they superimposed his head on Shaw and it looks off because Anakin never wore those clothes. Even if it was Shaw it would look odd now that we know what Anakin used to wear, but back in the OT days, I, and many others I'm sure, assumed Old Ben and Anakin's garbs were the full Jedi clothing, not retired Jedi recluse garbs.

 

[pixletwin]

I actually prefer the symmetry of yoda flanked by 2 jedi in OT duds better. I agree about the reshoot, but if it were done right I still prefer Anakin to wear the OT clothes.

 

[MaulFan]

I actually prefer the symmetry of yoda flanked by 2 jedi in OT duds better. I agree about the reshoot, but if it were done right I still prefer Anakin to wear the OT clothes.

It is definitely a better look than Gothakin's clothes, plus the black wouldn't have shown well in ghost form.

 

[TOE]

WHO WOULD WIN IN A FIGHT ? !!!!


GHOST FORM LUKE

Vs.

GHOST FORM MAUL


?????​

 

[MaulFan]

WHO WOULD WIN IN A FIGHT ? !!!!


GHOST FORM LUKE

Vs.

GHOST FORM MAUL


?????​

There could be no fight, the ability to communicate with the living comes through the light side of the Force.

 

[The ill Jedi]

Here is my interpretation:

I believe that each Jedi's 'Force Ghost' appears as they did when they died. In essence Anakin Skywalker died (ceased to exist) when he became Darth Vader, therefore it's logical to me that he appears as he did just before he turned to the Dark Side.

 

[pixletwin]

There could be no fight, the ability to communicate with the living comes through the light side of the Force.

MaulFan is correct.

 

[pixletwin]

Here is my interpretation:

I believe that each Jedi's 'Force Ghost' appears as they did when they died. In essence Anakin Skywalker died (ceased to exist) when he became Darth Vader, therefore it's logical to me that he appears as he did just before he turned to the Dark Side.

That would be a good arguement except that Ghost Anakin has no scars.

 

[The ill Jedi]

That would be a good arguement except that Ghost Anakin has no scars.

Simply overlooked by Lucas' staff at the time of the reshoot. They had it right except for that small detail they missed.

 

[p!tu]

Lucas is gay and Darth Maul owns the Star Wars Universe

 

[pixletwin]

Simply overlooked by Lucas' staff at the time of the reshoot. They had it right except for that small detail they missed.

 

[p!tu]

Simply overlooked by Lucas' staff at the time of the reshoot. They had it right except for that small detail they missed.

Like the eyebrows on a burnt victim! like VADER!

 

[pickard]

Again, I don't think the force has anything to do with how high you can jump or how you could/could not beat. My view of the force is a bit more zen.

I understand that viewpoint, PT, and I realized before submitting that my post would come off as shallow, but he wasn't jumping that high because of his enormous calf muscles. That was the force, and in his warrior days Obi-Wan seemed more like he was in constant and deeper communion with the force.

 

[The ill Jedi]

Did you even read my take?

Also, read below.

Like the eyebrows on a burnt victim! like VADER!

Go back and read my take on it, he wasn't 'Anakin' anymore, he was DARTH VADER when he fought Obi-Wan and got burned. He appeared as ANAKIN SKYWALKER to Luke at the end of RotJ and the scar I am referring to is the one over hs eye.

Do you guys understand!?!

 

[p!tu]

Go back and read my take on it, he wasn't 'Anakin' anymore, he was DARTH VADER. He appeared as ANAKIN SKYWALKER to Luke at the end of RotJ and the scar I am referring to is the one over hs eye.

what im talking about is When Luke takes the helmet off Vader he has eyebrows! and hes supposed to be burnt everywere! I think they fixed that in the SE dvds

 

[The ill Jedi]

what im talking about is When Luke takes the helmet off Vader he has eyebrows! and hes supposed to be burnt everywere! I think they fixed that in the SE dvds

Ahh, gotcha! Minor overlook there too huh?

 

[p!tu]

Ahh, gotcha! Minor overlook there too huh?

Exacto!!!!! MAN!! it took you long enough!!!!

 

[pixletwin]

Funny, I understood exactly what you wrote the first time I read it. I just thought it was a cop out answer. Pure speculation. Hence the ""

 

[The ill Jedi]

Funny, I understood exactly what you wrote the first time I read it. I just thought it was a cop out answer. Pure speculation. Hence the ""

Hey, I'm not making excuses for the guy, I think it's stupid to overlook something so important. I just think that's exactly what happened and there in lies the problem with re-working classic movies.

Greedo shooting first

 

[pixletwin]

Ok Ill. I have just one question for you then... Do you believe Anakin had a ghost mechanical arm or a ghost flesh arm?