WhoaItsJBot
Super Freak
I think people were expecting a movie where (SPOILERS TO FOLLOW) Batman wasn't hellbent on murdering Superman. Perhaps if they let the World's Greatest Detective have a bit more motivation for breaking his lifetime code to kill, audiences would respond in a bit more a positive tone. Conversely, if they're going to make Batman the villain, they needed to really commit to it. Dark Knight Returns worked because they were not afraid to make Superman the villain. Since we didn't have a past Batman to compare him to, the Batman presented in the film didn't seem like an extreme figure who had lost his way. So when he was beating on Superman, it was just sad and depressing, not the triumphant fun of Dark Knight Returns, or an ominous figure who had "lived long enough to become the villain." They tried to have their cake and eat it too, and if that weren't enough, the movie's narrative kept being interrupted by dream sequences that did nothing to further to plot, but merely advertised the coming Justice League movie.
I'm a huge Batman fan, and there's a problem when my favorite scenes in the movie are of Superman. (Glad the Man of Steel finally took a fight to space to spare innocents.) Although I'd rather the movie be truer to the source material, I can even accept the level of Bat-murder in line with Batman and Batman Returns. I didn't hate this film, but I didn't like much in it, either. I plan on seeing it again to see if I can find the redeeming qualities that others seem to be finding, but as of now, I find it hard to root for a film in which you can't even root for Batman.
Also, wouldn't Lex have been for effective if he'd been true to his current comic book character? The Doomsday introduction would have made a lot more sense coming from a scheming genius rather than a raving madman.
I agree with everything you said. I personally found the anti-Superman theme to drag on to the point of being tiresome. I like Cavill but perhaps he needs a new director to really shine as Superman, and this is coming from a longtime Snyder fan. For example, Superman Returns did a good job of showing Superman in a positive light as he tried to minimize the casualties in Metropolis from the Kryptonite landmass. That's exactly what I want to see with Cavill, but instead Snyder chose to show Superman just hovering over the family on the rooftop.
When the battle between the two finally starts it feels forced and unnecessary,
and Clark barely even tried to get the message across about Luthor having his mother captive.
killing off Superman so early served no purpose. Most of the movie was spent pointing accusing fingers at him and suddenly everyone, including Batman, loved him at the end?
Man-Bat in that one dream sequence with the bleeding wall?
On the bright side I thought the dynamic between Alfred and Bruce was great, and Wonder Woman was pretty cool.