When dealing with hand made, 12" dolls/figures, I don't think anything is going to be utterly spot on, 100% blemish free. There's obviously some things that are going to be worse than others, but I believe there will always be something you can find if you study it long enough that you're not going to particularly like.
For instance, my Supes has a small spot of some sort of translucent substance on the suit pattern on his rear end and the leg joints I think are a bit too stiff when moving them outward. They do move, but it takes some force. Neither bother me though. The spot sort of blends in with the suit when you look at it long enough and even then, it's on his arse and therefore, covered by the cape. The stiff leg joints don't bother me because I'm not going to be putting him in any crazy dynamic poses anyway that would require the legs to be far stretched and constantly moving them. Also, between having too loose or too stiff of joints, I'd personally take the latter. Despite those two things, there are a lot of things on mine that I feel are perfect: No blemishes in the paint on the sculpt or the neck, I think the way the cape sits at the shoulders on mine is perfect as compared to others I've seen, everything appears to be symmetrical, no apparent snags on the cape, etc. Because of those things, I'm keeping the one I have. I wouldn't want to run the risk of getting a new replacement and potentially have one of the things I love about the current figure, be compromised on the next.
I would never do this again.
