The HT Gunner didn't have a comparison piece. I easily passed on the SSC Snow Commander its accuracy is way below of what I wanted. BTW I still have 4 HT ANH Stormtroopers, no matter how accurate they are or not, they still are better than SSC's offering.
For me, troopers are all about the helmet sculpt, and HT undoubtedly dropped the ball on their stormie (the snowie was a bullesye.) You can argue about armor sculpts but if you miss the boat on the helmet sculpt on a SW trooper, you miss the boat in my book. The body quality and armor on the HT stormie is stellar, but I've spent years trying to swap out or mod helmets for my HT stormies and sandies.
The hours I spent trying to fix/mod that sandie helmet... arrrgh... I gave up on the stormie and just used the Marmit Sandie helmet which, while a somewhat soft (vinyl) sculpt and some inaccuracies (chin and decals,) at a glance looks kind of like the hero ANH helmet. Way more than the HT sculpt.
For me as a customizer, I can tweak stuff like armor and body on the Snowie Commander but the helmet has to be solid, and close to screen accurate. While the thickness of the flare and the curve of cowl are a bit off, overall the helmet is close to screen accurate. Would I have preferred the HT to be released? Obvioulsy - anyone would, but it doesn't mean the SSC helmet sculpt isn't close to accurate.
And the HT gunner is "empirically" crappy - with an undersized helmet, goofy/skeletal Vader V1 hands, easy-tear pleather tunic (that was in theory designed to be removable...,) a very sub-par jumpsuit cut/sew (compare it side-by-side to the SSC TIE jumpsuit - no comparison whatsoever, even though the SSC jumpsuits do flare at the thigh pockets too much) and the single most inaccurate rendition of a SW blaster since Hasbro's final 12" days; based on a nerf gun cosplayers use. It doesn't need a comparison piece with that list.
That's a first. I have never heard this from anyone in my life.
I actually think the very best look for stormies is the ESB look - which is cleaner versions of the ANH look with black mouth/teeth. I like that look even more than the stunt ANH look. I still have a nostaligic soft spot for the ROTJ stormie look, even if ROTJ stormies are almost laughably wonky-looking from head to toe. It was like literally everything went wrong when they tried to mass produce stormies.