I wouldn't do it personally. I always prefer the older more collectible pieces.
I would be on the fence on this one as well. On the one hand you get 2excellent satues with a more modern look. However, you also have a great "grail" that from a collectors stand point will be harder to get as time goes on. I guess it depends on your point of view. 2 for 1 is a great deal especially when its the 2 statues in question, but from a rarity stand point its tough call to make. In the end I think I'm with Bodie and I would keep the older collectible. Good luck!!!!