Re: J.J. Abrams' Star Trek
Before I begin I haven't read all the posts so if I cover something that has been said before please don't yell at me or throw broken medicom spidey pieces (sorry Lerath)
I'm on the fence with this one. I like the franchise and I don't really think it has been Justice lately. Voyager and Enterprise were awful, and Nemesis kinda dropped the ball.
The plot of the new movie appears to be that Eirc Bana, a Romulan named Nero, takes his team to the past and old Spock travels back too to stop him from mucking up things. Those of you who remember when Spock was on Next Gen he was working with the Romluans to reunify them with Vulcan.
Anyway they meet up with Pike about to court marshall Kirk for the whole Kobiashi Maru thing. I think this has potential. No it's not exactly the StarFleet adcademy movie they promised but it's an interessting take on how to continue the story.
Anyway, my Wife is a Trekkie, I'm not talking just a fan. My wife could tell you every Captain of the Enterprise, what kind of vessels they were, and tell you the specs and weapons, well you get the idea
She's furious because Pike is going to be way older than Kirk, apparently they went to Starfleet together, and that The Enterpriase is going to be in the movie when neither man had the ship at the time the movie is supposed to take place.
Star Trek's problem is that it has become a corporate whore. At Least Star Wars has Lucas at the helm at all times and no stupid studio monkey who thinks he can write can screw things up. Also I believe that Star Trek is great, it's iconic yada yada. IN my opinion it has always been on the verge of great storytelling but drops the ball at the last second. The Dominio War was thier best arc I think. But when I'm done watching the show it doesn't stay with me. StarWars has held my attention for years. I'm obsessed with it. Star Trek is kinda like " OKay that's cool" then the movie or show is over and i'm over it. I don't wait patiently for each new installment.
And Star Trek is way too politically correct. The Federation as a whole always has the uinverse's best interest at heart. We have abandoned all our hatred and bigotry. Babylon 5 was way more believable, Earth gets it's first victory in a war right after they begin exploring the universe and we think we are the end all be all of the galaxy. The during the Earth Civil war arc, the president nearly destroys the planet when his power is threatend. Star Trek never questions how Earthlings would truly react with so much power. Then again I'm a pesimist, that and I got a hug from Claudia Christian at dragoncon and she's still hot.
Anyway I'll give the new movie a shot, and continue to listen to my wife Yell and holler about how they have trashed her religion.