Thank you for the condolences. Not trying to be disrespectful but that's about all I can agree on. This is my opinion and mine only. I think to many parents try the softer gentler way of parenting. I go to stores, restaurants and see kids running rough shod through the establishment. Way to often I see young kids actually slap at their parents. Most of the time all you see the parent do is just shrug it off, say "oh well, kids will be kids".
I don't understand Celtics views with his parents. I don't find it acceptable that he TELLS parents that if he feels like it he is going to smoke, drink whatever he tells them, especially if they help him with his hobby. I think your son is pretty young right now, I look forward to updates on how accepting you are going to be with him as he gets more rambuntious as we boys do.
You say you're going to let your son make his own mistakes? Are you going to let him touch a hot stove? Cross a street without looking? Of course not. So why would you let him do stuff like smoking or drinking just because you had a long talk about it. My kids are to old now for spankings (yes, I believe in it)but will not hesitate to take phones, IPODs, outings or whatever it takes to get my point across. I have posted it before but will again. I have 2 daughters 16 and 14 and 2 step-daughters 15 and 12. I am firm with them, but they adore me and I them. I hope your parenting works out for you, but I know what worked for me.
As far as being hypocritical, you're 100 % correct. I parent by "do as I say not as I do". If your son comes up to you at the age of 11 and says he wants to have sex with the 16 yr. old next door, are you going to think "well, I have sex and I'd be a hypocrite to tell him he can't? If so then I may as well not respond anymore, because our parental methods are polar opposites.