Marvel Studios/Sony - SPIDER-MAN: HOMECOMING

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I'm not a fan of the Stark-inspired suits at all, but in the grand scheme of the film, that's a pretty minor quibble for me. While we have WB destroying everything enjoyable about those great characters, and when there is a lot of uncertainty and lack of focus at Fox, Marvel and Sony find a way to give Spider-Man a terrific shot in the arm. I'll take it!
 
If you haven't been a dyed in the wool Spidey fan since being a toddler like me, you'll never understand, Bat-boy. :nana:

He behaves as a teenage Spidey should. Not just as Parker, but as Spider-Man. All those little things he does throughout the film--his friendships, the way he fights, the way he struggles with adversity, his attitude--add up to the most fulfilling version of Spidey so far. Yes, Spidey 2 is a terrific film, and Tobey did a really good job as Parker. And of course, the motivation was best fleshed out by that version of Spidey. But Raimi never did the fun-loving, joke cracking, and ultimately, "street-level" Spidey the way he deserves. There was a stilted, and even surrealistic quality to the Raimi films. Part of that is his style. Part of that may have been a sign of the times. But it was there. The Spidey action scenes were usually pretty lacking. That wasn't evident here. I loved the opening scene in Amazing Spider-Man 2. And at the time, wished they would have somehow expanded that into a full length film instead of going way off the rails as they did, in terms of how Spidey (not Parker, who never made sense to me in the Garfield films) was represented. This film is, essentially that. The stakes aren't world shattering. The story isn't overly convoluted. There is an air of real freshness and fun to the whole thing. That's not all that Spidey is. But it is the core spirit of the character. That distinguishes him from Batman, and Captain America, and the bulk of other well known comic characters out there. Guilt isn't novel, and isn't always on the surface in Spidey's stories frankly, so it's no huge loss that they don't beat us over the head with that. . .again. . .here. This film mashed together a great version of Peter, and a great version of Spidey, and did so much better than the other films. And I'm really optimistic about the future of the character and franchise as a result.


Eh, there's a lot of key stuff missing from the Homecoming Spider-Man that the Raimi one has though. That's why the whole "spirit" thing caught me off guard.


Holland has a couple of great scenes that do what you speak of (when he chooses to go find Vulture instead of going to the pool party with his friends, when he's struggling to lift the debris he's buried in, straight out of Amazing Spider-Man #31) but the Maguire Spider-Man has so many more. I guess I see your point about the street level stuff, but it's not like there wasn't street level crimes in the first couple of movies. The whole thing with the Green Goblin and the bridge wasn't even that huge as far as stakes go, so.


I do like Homecoming quite a bit, but I don't think it crushes the first two movies in terms of faithfulness and fee fees or anything like that. Both versions have elements that the other doesn't. Things like Uncle Ben, responsibility, J Jonah Jameson, an old Aunt May that will make you pancakes, etc. freelance photography, etc. are pretty big deals for the Spider-Man lore. Bigger than Tony Stark and the Avengers in my opinion.
 
Well we all have our own ideas about what a character should be like. In some ways, this is similar to how I was floored by Nolan's handling of Batman. There, as you know as well as anyone, Nolan took a score of liberties. The villains in particular were almost complete re-imaginings, and there are a lot of logical inconsistencies in Batman's behavior and motivations. But for me, it was still capturing a great version of Batman that felt right to me. Burton's version never did that, even as a kid, and Snyder's version sure as hell doesn't do that. even though both did certain things that I liked. But others will disagree and latch onto other versions, and it's good that so many of us can find that version that best connects with them. If Flashpoint does reboot things and gives us a 23 year old Batman, maybe that will work better for others still.
 
3FwBhhw.gif

Terrifying GIF. Jesus that's what I'm afraid I look like when people force me to dance.
 
Eh, there's a lot of key stuff missing from the Homecoming Spider-Man that the Raimi one has though. That's why the whole "spirit" thing caught me off guard.


Holland has a couple of great scenes that do what you speak of (when he chooses to go find Vulture instead of going to the pool party with his friends, when he's struggling to lift the debris he's buried in, straight out of Amazing Spider-Man #31) but the Maguire Spider-Man has so many more. I guess I see your point about the street level stuff, but it's not like there wasn't street level crimes in the first couple of movies. The whole thing with the Green Goblin and the bridge wasn't even that huge as far as stakes go, so.


I do like Homecoming quite a bit, but I don't think it crushes the first two movies in terms of faithfulness and fee fees or anything like that. Both versions have elements that the other doesn't. Things like Uncle Ben, responsibility, J Jonah Jameson, an old Aunt May that will make you pancakes, etc. freelance photography, etc. are pretty big deals for the Spider-Man lore. Bigger than Tony Stark and the Avengers in my opinion.

What the **** is this ****? The new DiFabio? Learn how to disagree like the above post when discussing Star Wars and you might actually be an interesting fellow worth keeping around. :tap
 
Learn how to disagree like the above post when discussing Star Wars

Nah, waste of time. My arguments and posts against it will just get deleted when no one is looking after a couple of days. :lol
 
Khev was better when he had Cap on the brain and not Stah Wahs. I want that old Khev back. The Khev with the Steve Rogers avatar.


Also, Homecoming > Rogue One

The Lego Death Star falling on the floor and breaking into 1000 pieces in Spider-Man felt more like Star Wars than anything in iRebel: Another Star Wars story.
 
I'm not a fan of the Stark-inspired suits at all, but in the grand scheme of the film, that's a pretty minor quibble for me. While we have WB destroying everything enjoyable about those great characters, and when there is a lot of uncertainty and lack of focus at Fox, Marvel and Sony find a way to give Spider-Man a terrific shot in the arm. I'll take it!
You're right. Overall each of these elements are minor. But when every single one of these minor elements are changed, they add up to basically a brand new character.

It just doesn't feel like Spider-Man to me when everything that makes Spider-Man the character we know and love is gone.
 
Nah, waste of time. My arguments and posts against it will just get deleted when no one is looking after a couple of days. :lol

Yeah right. You know you could totally be one of the top "grab a beer and talk movies with" guys here if you didn't try to troll and derail threads so much. Yeah I'm going there with tough love right here in the thread. You don't have to like a single freaking movie that comes out and you can go off about what you hate in SW, the MCU, and all of that like so many people here do or *like you just did about Homecoming* with karamazov.

Some of us are going to be superfans about whatever and yeah you can call it out if we can't shut up about it in every other thread (lol, I get it guys, I get it) but why try to make people who have loved this crap their whole lives feel like they're wasting their time trying to discuss this stuff? I'm just making general observations on past behavior here. Some of your roasts are hilariously entertaining, and some of your praise is damn spot on and insightful, but then there's this whole other side where you just piss on everything and do your whole "sowing discord" shtick. Come on now, all of these threads should be big enough for everyone here and the entire gamut of opinions from positive to negative without certain people trying to bring the enthusiasm in a thread way down every time they're in the mood.

And you know I haven't censored any of your opinions on Star Wars. But **** with my Felicity pic and yeah I'll cut that **** down. You know she's my girl, on and off screen! Okay maybe not off, she did just get engaged but hey, we'll always have 10 seconds in Orlando, lol. I'm trying to be funny here, and I'm trying to be light, but it's just going to be this big elephant in the room where if people just can't treat everyone else like bros and just be decent and respectful then it's that scene in Heat that I've referenced before. "Now that we're sitting here face to face like a couple of regular guys, then if I have to take you down I'm not gonna like it."

And I realize that at the end of the day I'm just another guy who wants to talk shop about movies so as a mod I try to recognize my own shortcomings, pick and choose my battles, and all that. It honestly kind of bums me out that I didn't see the version of you above where you just listened to karamazov's points, refuted some, acknowledged and agreed with others and so on back when we were having our big Rogue One back and forths (<--there you go Clown Prince I know you were waiting for that, lol) but...I'll get over it. I'll get over it. Really I will :) But still, just sayin'.

And with that let me give a semi-optimistic :duff
 

:rotfl

Oh man, so repped. *You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to The Clown Prince of Crime again.* What? I've repped you before? Did someone hack my account or something?

Khev was better when he had Cap on the brain and not Stah Wahs. I want that old Khev back. The Khev with the Steve Rogers avatar.


Also, Homecoming > Rogue One

The Lego Death Star falling on the floor and breaking into 1000 pieces in Spider-Man felt more like Star Wars than anything in iRebel: Another Star Wars story.

Ha, I want the new DiFabio and you want the old Khev. Dang it. :lol
 
You're right. Overall each of these elements are minor. But when every single one of these minor elements are changed, they add up to basically a brand new character.

It just doesn't feel like Spider-Man to me when everything that makes Spider-Man the character we know and love is gone.
Well, I'm reasonably sure we're going to hear about Ben, and get JJJ in the next Spidey film, anyway. Some of this we just haven't seen.

I actually liked the decision to shake up the approach to MJ, though. The gorgeous supermodel is something kids would fantasize about, but it's not very believable. Or for that matter, very relatable. In the comics, the first time Peter sees MJ he is floored by how gorgeous she is. In this film, he almost totally ignores her based on looks. Liz is the proxy for comic MJ. But Zenyatta (or whatever her name is) is actually very beautiful, and I'm sure will look that way in future films. But they're allowing the relationship to build up more organically. That's something teens go through, and can make for a richer story I think.
 
Well, I'm reasonably sure we're going to hear about Ben, and get JJJ in the next Spidey film, anyway. Some of this we just haven't seen.

I actually liked the decision to shake up the approach to MJ, though. The gorgeous supermodel is something kids would fantasize about, but it's not very believable. Or for that matter, very relatable. In the comics, the first time Peter sees MJ he is floored by how gorgeous she is. In this film, he almost totally ignores her based on looks. Liz is the proxy for comic MJ.

Then why not just give MJ Liz' arc? Liz was basically the same character as MJ. And that felt realistic. You'd be surprised how much the nerdy yet boyish charm can actually work for certain high school guys; and how many girls dig that.

I just hated that they introduced this bizarre, quirky character and then tried to sell us that she was actually a character that we had known for years. Because nothing but her nickname is the same......
 
Yeah right. You know you could totally be one of the top "grab a beer and talk movies with" guys here if you didn't try to troll and derail threads so much. Yeah I'm going there with tough love right here in the thread. You don't have to like a single freaking movie that comes out and you can go off about what you hate in SW, the MCU, and all of that like so many people here do or *like you just did about Homecoming* with karamazov.

Some of us are going to be superfans about whatever and yeah you can call it out if we can't shut up about it in every other thread (lol, I get it guys, I get it) but why try to make people who have loved this crap their whole lives feel like they're wasting their time trying to discuss this stuff? I'm just making general observations on past behavior here. Some of your roasts are hilariously entertaining, and some of your praise is damn spot on and insightful, but then there's this whole other side where you just piss on everything and do your whole "sowing discord" shtick. Come on now, all of these threads should be big enough for everyone here and the entire gamut of opinions from positive to negative without certain people trying to bring the enthusiasm in a thread way down every time they're in the mood.

And you know I haven't censored any of your opinions on Star Wars. But **** with my Felicity pic and yeah I'll cut that **** down. You know she's my girl, on and off screen! Okay maybe not off, she did just get engaged but hey, we'll always have 10 seconds in Orlando, lol. I'm trying to be funny here, and I'm trying to be light, but it's just going to be this big elephant in the room where if people just can't treat everyone else like bros and just be decent and respectful then it's that scene in Heat that I've referenced before. "Now that we're sitting here face to face like a couple of regular guys, then if I have to take you down I'm not gonna like it."

And I realize that at the end of the day I'm just another guy who wants to talk shop about movies so as a mod I try to recognize my own shortcomings, pick and choose my battles, and all that. It honestly kind of bums me out that I didn't see the version of you above where you just listened to karamazov's points, refuted some, acknowledged and agreed with others and so on back when we were having our big Rogue One back and forths (<--there you go Clown Prince I know you were waiting for that, lol) but...I'll get over it. I'll get over it. Really I will :) But still, just sayin'.

And with that let me give a semi-optimistic :duff



WTF!


I definitely don't want to talk movies and have a beer with you now, you sound like one of my exes. You'd chop me up if you could!


Anyway, I like Homecoming. It was a good Spider-Man movie. A nice palate cleanser after the last two. I wish Marvel stayed true to this film's ending and didn't feel the need to shove him into Infinity Wars. I liked that he turned down Stark, the Avengers, the new Iron man suit and all the fame that would come with it. It was a very humble and Spider-Man-like thing to do.
 
I actually thought Liz was a good level of pretty without being unrealistically or unrelatably gorgeous. And when Zendaya gets fixed up she'll basically look like Liz did. So I'm fine with how they're going with that. You could believe that a guy like Holland would be really into Liz, and that Liz could even find him appealing, so when "MJ" makes the transformation into that same look it could potentially be a nice "wowza I've had a Liz in sheep's clothing all along" moment.
 
You'd be surprised how much the nerdy yet boyish charm can actually work for certain high school guys; and how many girls dig that.

Not at my high school :lol Though maybe things have changed with the "millennial" generation.

They could have made Liz MJ, and just changed Spidey's love interest altogether when she was forced to move cross-country. But again, I like how convention got turned on its head in this case. Mary Jane was never a great character in the comic, anyway. I remember in the '80s and '90s when some writers tried to flesh her character out a bit more, and it just led to some cringe-worthy story arcs. The best stuff she did--being there for Peter when he was at his lowest points--didn't require her to be a super-model.


Anyway, I like Homecoming. It was a good Spider-Man movie. A nice palate cleanser after the last two. I wish Marvel stayed true to this film's ending and didn't feel the need to shove him into Infinity Wars. I liked that he turned down Stark, the Avengers, the new Iron man suit and all the fame that would come with it. It was a very humble and Spider-Man-like thing to do.
I agree with you on that. A very Spidey-esque ending, apparently soon to be undone for the greater good of making Kevin Feige happy.
 
Back
Top