cr0w
Super Freak
COUGH*bullsh**COUGH. i am a HUGE batman fan, just got done watching B89 for the zillioneth time. i have yet to find anything wrong with the film besides nicholsons belly, and even then thats a small complaint. everyone was perfect, production design was fantastic, very entertaining even all these years later. anyone who says its not batman is either blind or just plain ignorant. saying its not your style is one thing. saying it fails as a batman film is completely false. nolan got more wrong then burton. ALOT more wrong. plus, his movies just arent fun! and take themselves way too seriously.
Not going to tell you your opinion's wrong, because obviously it's not. You like them, probably for the same reasons I dislike them.
They just felt, to me, like Tim Burton movies with Batman casually wandering into a scene here and there. I can't stand Nicholson's Joker, mainly because there was no characterization there. It was Jack turned up to 11. I don't see Joker, I see Jack on a coke binge. Never liked his turn as Joker, even when I was seeing it on opening night back in '89.
The reasons I say it fails as a Batman film are a.) Batman kills dozens, if not hundreds of goons willy-nilly when he blows up the Axis Chemical Plant, b.) The retcon of Napier being the person that killed Bruce's parents completely destroys Batman's never being able to get justice for his parents, which fuels his need to become Batman in the first place, c.) The above-mentioned lack of characterization for The Joker, d.) The pussification of Commissioner Gordon, he was a complete non-factor in the entire series, e.) Gotham, instead of being a real, living city, being turned into a gothic, monolithic soundstage, f.) The Prince soundtrack, g.) The complete lack of Batman being any sort of physical presence, h.) Batman's willing murder of Joker at the end, i.) Billy Dee Williams as Harvey Dent....
I could go on and on. I mean, I'm not a Tim Burton fan at all, which probably influences my feelings on the movie, but I've always thought it was a boring, drab, completely wrong take on the characters, and nothing will ever change that. There was no respect whatsoever for the source material, the pop culture tie-ins were just completely ill-advised, and there really wasn't one likable character in the films Burton directed. The only thing I've ever liked about them was the Batsuit in the first one. Everything else I would burn if given the chance.