Going by the side by side pic, I think the one on the right looks much better though I'm not sure which one is made by who. Both are really good, but I think the one on the right has better proportions and the face sculpt looks better to me as well. Like I just said though, I think either purchase looks to be really solid. They both capture the character well and they both capture different element so I'd be reluctant to say one is actually the superior between the two.