Watched today and had zero expectations but ended up really enjoying it.
That was my approach as well. It's part of the Predator series so I wasn't expecting much, yet it really surprised me.
Felt like a return to form after so much garbage this franchise has suffered through, especially the 2018 atrocity, the different time period was a breath of fresh air and while the predator design could've been better I appreciate them showing that like the humans it was still developing it's tech, one could make the argument the predators we see in 1 and 2 look that way because they've been evolving with humans as they've hunted them over the years but looks aside it has some of the most enjoyable predator action in all the franchise, too bad it also turned dumb torwards the end but at least in this movie it's a bit more believable since it's mask was taken. Gore was a bonus too.
I got the sense it was young and on its first hunt. It got cocky, and the arrogance grew to the point where it was literally daring the prey on several occasions to kill it. Being able to paralyse his enemies like that more than once set him up for his fatal error.
I also liked Naru as a protagonist and how she used her own mistakes, knowledge of the land and the predator's own tricks to her advantage, her dingo was also a neat addition as he actually aided her a number of times and she would've been dead if not for the pup.
The dog was actually historically accurate too, which impressed me as so many common breeds aren't much more than hundred years or so old.
That, along with the smattering of Comanche and the cinematography itself, gave the impression that the film wanted to be something better than the franchise it represented.
Is it Predator 1 or 2? Hell no, those are timeless classics but for me it can stand alongside those films, having 3 distinct protagonists, eras and settings actually makes for a pretty cool "trilogy" for me especially with that tie in and I appreciate them trying to do something geniunely different for once even if some of it didn't work, mostly the cgi, new predator face design and the long first act but overall I had a good time with it and would like to see more Predator flicks set in other time periods or even a sequel with Naru to see how that tie in shows up in another movie.
P2 is my favourite, as I wrote before, due to the expanded environment and being the first to put Predator into the Alien universe.
P1 seems a bit cheesy now, especially in contrast to
Prey, due it being a macho muscleman vehicle for the actors, which was very much of its time. Arnie was flexing his muscles in the jungle, Stallone had just flexed his in the city while chewing on a matchstick in
Cobra.
PS: I'm actually a bit surprised to see so many hate it on here, really feels like a lot of people have had their ability to enjoy things poisoned by nostalgia, and this isn't the majority on here but I won't even try to understand people online saying it's "woke" because it has a female protagonist, grown men throwing hissy fits if a movie or show has women and people of other races and gender in it has become just as tiresome as Hollywood's endless virtue signaling.
As you wrote in another post, some people selectively forget that Ripley and Sarah were doing these things decades ago.