Except for the bucket, it really looks bad. But when you put it up next to any of the 1/6 collectibles from Sideshow, Marmit or even (gasp!) Medicom, it really looks pretty poor in hand. That's the VOTC (Vintage Original Trilogy Collection) 12" Stormtrooper from 2004, just before Hasbro handed Sideshow a sub-license to make 1/6 premium figures for the collector market.
The second more doll-like version is the original "Collector Series" Hasbro Stormtrooper from 1997-98.
In its prime it was one of the best! Haha. I was so stoked when the line with the Hasbro Trooper and Boba Fett came out.