I don't know what Honest Trailers is, so....
I got why he was shot, it's just surprising that he survived all of that AND M seemed to know he was alive in retirement. And why he felt betrayed. So he got shot in (almost) the same place by both the French dude and Moneypenny? I thought it was the other side for some reason. So the fragments were from the French guy's gun, since that's how they connected it to him. I was wondering why everyone was only focusing on his right shoulder. I thought the scar Silva touched was the same one that Bond sliced open....so you're saying it isn't?
And no, the ice part was just a dumb move imo
You can clearly see the the ground on both sides of the lake when he first steps on it. And when Silva was standing there, on land, with his gun pointed at Bond, it wasn't far at all..and Silva was basically a straight distance to the chapel after he turned away from Bond to fell through the ice.
For as much time as Bond had to take to stop running and see how thin the ice was before finally stepping on it, he easily could have been sprinting full speed safely on dirt and grass. For someone who is as aware as 007, I found it a bit dimwitted when just about anybody else would go to the left or the right and get there at the same time, if not faster.