That probably depends on how nitpicky you are. Some will tear it apart for the smallest of reasons.
Even though I like the original trilogy, I’m not so enamoured by them either as I watched them later in life. Probably just prior to the prequels coming out.
I don’t consider myself nitpicky. I enjoyed the PT for crying out loud. Still do. The OT is something I watch 2 or 3 times a year so I’d like any recent SW related shows to at least not negate any of its lore or established fictional perimeters. I’d like for any new SW to have a similar tone to the OT as well. Some things endure due to change. Others to familiarity. Star Wars for me is the latter.