I'm getting so sick of hearing this, he was just as bad as everyone else. Yea he looked the part, yea he sounded the part, but in episodes 2 & 3, man there are some unbearable moments. Off the top of my head: when he is talking to Dex in the diner, and then when he is talking to Padme in RotS " I saw him...killing younglings"
I wanna puke.
Am I the only one?
No. You are not.
But there were some great moments too.
Ian McDermaid had some wonderful acting moments. As did Liam Neeson. Heck, I even liked Jimmy Smit's acting and the Swedish lady who played Schmi Skywalker [sic].
The script was a far worse problem than bad acting in the PT.