So even though at *no point* in any film is it established that droids can be trusted battle pilots you're saying that all the good guys had to do to win the war in minutes would be to take some protocol droids, hand over their *three* capital ships (or five Calamari cruisers from the OT) and....crash them? Genius military tactics!
Yeah, I think in most scenarios the goal is to keep your large ships, not build them just to blow them up or drive them into something. I'm surprised this one is such a sticking point for some. Seemed like one of the highlights.