The Avengers VS The Dark Knight

[EXOTICLEX]

imo it's not fair to put the Avengers up against TDK because it was released 4 years ago. Now once the TDKR is all said and done then we can revisit this type of poll....

 

[jye4ever]

Avengers.

**** Dark Knight and for that matter all Nolan Batman films.

Jedi, are you ill.

 

[wofford29]

Fitting since the latest and greatest fad of the moment is going against the latest and greatest fad of a few years ago.

Fitting like a square in a circle.

 

[intothevoid]

Jedi, are you ill.

 

[thenammagazine]

imo it's not fair to put the Avengers up against TDK because it was released 4 years ago. Now once the TDKR is all said and done then we can revisit this type of poll....

 

[hbklb]

i voted for the dark knight.....
I liked avengers but as odd as it sounds it was too happy and almost kiddy at some moments..... They are both amazing though. I choose to let both wheldon and nolan live for another day. lol

 

[The Josh]

TDK is a awesome movie and I enjoy watching it but The Avengers for me personally is just heads and shoulders above it.

 

[intothevoid]

Poll is redundant.

Worldwide poll already in progress:

https://www.imdb.com/chart/top

 

[hbklb]

lol imdb top 250 is never wrong

 

[carbo-fation]

This reminds me of when IM came out before TDK and every slut and her ______ raved it as the best thing ever only to be schooled by Pope Nolan and TDK.

 

[hbklb]

i forgot all about all the hype(rightfully so) Iron man got...... then dark knight came out and Iron man no longer existed. lol

 

[thenammagazine]

This reminds me of when IM came out before TDK and every slut and her ______ raved it as the best thing ever only to be schooled by Pope Nolan and TDK.

Yup. Irony being if Ledger hadn't died and the movie received hundreds of millions worth of dollars in free advertising, the competition would've been as close as this poll.

 

[intothevoid]

Yup. Irony being if Ledger hadn't died and the movie received hundreds of millions worth of dollars in free advertising, the competition would've been as close as this poll.

If TDKR makes anything approaching $1bn worldwide, you will be proven wrong.

 

[thenammagazine]

If TDKR makes anything approaching $1bn worldwide, you will be proven wrong.

You know it won't.

And then you'll go back to your textbook, "I don't let box office determine what's good to me." response.

 

[DarkMagic]

The Dark Knight for me. Period.

 

[intothevoid]

You know it won't.

And then you'll go back to your textbook, "I don't let box office determine what's good to me." response.

Well i've already said that. I could be the only one who ever sees TDKR and it could still be amazing

Actually, seeing how much Avengers is making, I think TDKR legitimately has a shot at matching TDK box office. Before Avengers' opening weekend, I thought TDKR will end up around $700-800MM worldwide, now i'm not so sure.

 

[Voorhees27]

Batman Begins 10/10

Avengers 9.5/10

TDK 9.4/10

So my answer is Avengers.

Although imo its somewhat apples to oranges it's still a fair comparison.

 

[BladeDJK]

I love them both honestly. Avengers though gets my vote because I felt it was just better. Not by much but still.

 

[Nuka Cola Kidd]

Avengers. TDK is sooo overrated. Yes Ledger was great, but he is the only that makes it a great movie. Without him, it's no different than BB.

 

[Voorhees27]

Avengers. TDK is sooo overrated. Yes Ledger was great, but he is the only that makes it a great movie without him, it's no different than BB.

So what you're saying is, without Ledger it's like BB's, an amazing film.