- Joined
- Jul 13, 2006
- Messages
- 9,124
- Reaction score
- 4,237
So is the ST looking better yet (or the PT for that matter)?
Um, no.
This show is certainly similar in it's failure. Unplanned, poorly written, inconsistent design with previously established SW aesthetic, directed by people more interested in character deconstruction and "wouldn't it be cool?" sequences and visuals than creating a coherent, myth-based story that would encourage repeated viewing and exposure than deepens the meaning and connection to its audience as well as great respect for what came before.
BOBF has been sadly shocking in it's execution. Some of the shock comes from seeing Favreau's name on the credits. How could the guy who gave us Ironman and The Mandalorian be the force behind such a disjointed, chaotic production? Just remember, that same guy gave us Zathura and two lifeless cartoon-to-"live-action" movies that while technically proficient, were creepy, empty and unwatchable.
Sometimes our enthusiasm for Star Wars blinds us to the fact that while we have over 40 years of appreciation and love for this franchise because of it's great story, relatable characters and glorious worldbuilding, the current regime that "owns" it regards it as an asset to be exploited to the max, not a touchstone to be treasured, respected and curated with care.
It's been interesting to read the discussion about Grogu's "choice" and his appearance (along with Mando) in this show. There was never a choice. This is entertainment by algorithm, not art. That made the "choice" moot. The profitable pair must not be broken up, not when there are more "aww"-filled adorable moments to exploit, even if it means short-changing the dramatic story possibilities for the two characters. The momentous conclusion to the Mandalorian's quest of returning Grogu to the Jedi was completely undone in the BOBF finale to provide the most cringe-inducing moments in SW since Jar Jar first stepped in front of Qui-Gon in TPM. That cringe at least had a means to an end with the story. The Grogu/Mando moments in BOBF only succeeded in gutting both characters and making them into caricatures of what had been presented up to that point. sad and short-sighted .
BOBF will rival the Sequel Trilogy in one other significant way...as the biggest missed opportunities in SW history to expand the story and introduce new ideas and elements in a way that makes that galaxy far, far away even more vital and interesting.
Disney/Lucasfilm may continue to make money and trade on the past of this franchise, but any more content like BOBF risks rendering this once-great and influential franchise into just another bloated bunch of content to be scrolled past on a streaming service...
This is the bottom line for Disney now.....
....soon to be rotting in a landfill near you.