I've never sat down to rewatch a single SW movie or show. I love the general universe, but the films themselves... eh. I don't much care for the LotR universe (though that might change when I finally read the books I've had on my shelf for years now), but I find the movies much more competently made and engrossing. However I've only seen them once as well. I prefer PotC if we're talking big set-piece focused action properties of the era. MCU flicks are middle of the road with some genuine moments of soul, and depending on the time I can put them on repeat while I'm doing something else. Mostly the Iron Man Trilogy & GotG. I think those have some soul in them. The rest, I don't know. Winter Soldier is a fine spyflick with capes and I've rewatched it multiple times. I find Doctor Strange easy to sit through too. Infinity War was the first case of the MCU trying to approach the scale of comic book events, so I'm partial to it, even though Endgame dropped the ball. Thor 1 & 2 are harmless, disposable fun, but that might be because I like Myth Sci-Fi types. I can't remember anything else. I wouldn't count any of them in my Top 100, but you get the point.
I don't consider any of them genuine filmmaking in the complete sense. LotR yeah, sure. And I'll give Lucas a lot of props for the technical aspects and what he tried to do, but I've never been able to see SW as films; they're just parts of the grander merchandising whole. I think the KotOR games have more merit, I think the Dark Horse EU comics had better world building and were more enjoyable, and so on. The movies are a part of the entire tapestry, and while they're the core, I find more enjoyment elsewhere. Maybe it's because I'm a lore type and I like all the worldbuilding; the more the merrier. Provided of course that it doesn't devolve to nonsense; sometimes less is more. But for me, aesthetics is the primary reason to be invested in anything. WH40K has tons of contradictory and stupid lore, but I love the aesthetics too much. It's not even the grimdark thing, I've just got a hardon for Space [Insert Past Culture], especially Antiquity stuff.
If we talk genuine filmmaking, I'm all over the place and I've never seen any of these flicks as "proper films". It might be elitist and pretentious, but I just never felt that. Even when I was a kid I saw them as fun distractions. The kind you catch at 16:00 on a Sunday evening. I always regarded them as watered down compared to the comics and cartoons, and even despised them for a time. It'd piss me off normies would talk about them when they didn't care about the 60 year lore behind them dammit! I was a stereotypical Fight Club/Donnie Darko type for a time, but I never went through the phase of popcorn blockbusters being my favourites. Now, I say this genuinely and without irony, but Tron Legacy is one of my favourite Sci-Fi movies and I wholeheartedly and utterly enjoy it more than any other blockbuster. I even count it amongst my favourite films in general. I don't know why. It didn't come out at a particular point in my life, it's not tied to any memories, nothing. And yet I love it. I rewatch it multiple times per year, usually during the Fall & Winter. I think it did in a single movie what the ST should've done, and did it much, much better.
Besides that, like I said, I'm all over the place. Visconti, Wes Anderson, Fincher, big names, small names, whatever, if it tickles my fancy I'll watch it. I have a penchant for Epics for Lawrence Of Arabia is usually in my Top 3, and I can easily sit through something like Il Gattopardo, but even a half fogoten drama like Michael Clayton is in my Top 20. In fact, Clooney's "Up In The Air" is one of my go-to comfy watches. So, you know, I might be into epic space battles, but there's no movie out there that gives me what I need, and especially not Star Wars. Maybe when I become God Emperor and finance my own WH40K Cinematic Universe...
Now that the dust has settled, I think the FoX-Men might be the best cape franchise. Nice blend of down to Earth drama and superheroics, the dated leather is now nostalgic, and there's some great casting and performances in there. It might be because I'm biased and think Fassbender/McAvoy and Stewart/McKellen elevate them. Things like Dark Phoenix and Origins were clearly trash, and there was a lot of nonsense in the other flicks too. An embarassment for the source, the forced politics that led to the brand getting overtaken Post-2000s, all the X-Men getting sidelined in favour of Wolverine, the trash Logan/Jean/Cyclops triangle being pushed. But I don't know, I find them easily watchable as movies first and foremost. X1, X2, FC, DOFP, all flow like films, not as disposable action schlock.
There's genuine chemistry between the cast, there's a specific aesthetic and it does pull off "X-Men but realistic" well compared to other attempts (concerning different cape properties I mean). Maybe it's because I grew to appreciate the comics of the era too, but as the years go by I tend to think that they had more good than bad. But like I said, I might be biased as X-Men is the one comic I'm still pulling these days. I've dropped Iron Man, GotG, Moon Knight, everything. It's not that I don't like those characters anymore, it's that I can just go through the issues online in 4 minutes and miss nothing. But X-Men's at a decently interesting place, so I'm still in for the ride. I suppose I like stories with big scopes, so I'm invested in the continuing X-Story. The large cast and again, scope, keep me coming back as I get both of what I crave. Not that I don't like smaller, self-contained character stories, but even then I prefer them in a larger context. I remember that quote by Jarsmuch who said that he doesn't care for the Emperors and Kings; give him a story about a man and his dog. Or something to that wavelength. I'm the opposite. I'll enjoy a war epic, but if I have to watch a character study, I prefer someone complex and interesting to follow. Anyway, I'm off the mark here, I was talking about the X-Men. But I think I've said what I needed to.
Moving on to other cape franchises, I guess there's Snyder's flicks, Nolan, Burton, but... eh. I can enjoy bits of Snyder's flicks, but he gets too carried away and just cannot handle all he wants to accomplish. I recently caught Aquaman again on tv, and while I still find it too "bright", I think it's the single most purely enjoyable and comic book-y flick out there. Hot leads, great sets, a huge scope, lots of fighting and fun with a nice enough basic and universal, almost mythical, message. It's the perfect capeflick in that sense. I was always a Namor guy (I prefer dicks and ***** to boyscouts), but between my growing appreciation for the flick, and how awful the MCU Atlantis casting is, I'm growing more and more into an Aquafan. I mean, at the end of the day, I like Atlantis as a concept and its ties to the myths, I don't care for the capeshit aspect all that much. Whichever is closer to my general aesthetics gets my vote. And that's why I'll be buying an AquaMomoa at some point and having him as a Namor stand-in in my display in the future.
If Lost Kingdom's even better, I could go for a proper Arthur & Mera display too. Sigh, I wish I was a Poseidon-looking GigaChad King with a redheaded GigaStacy Princess wife...
PS: Comparing the PT, even at its worst, with The Picture Book Of Beta Fatt is... Just...
I don't have that. I'll take a cross-section of the best each of my favourite IPs has to offer rather than zoning in on one IP, over half of which could be complete crap.
That's what I've been trying to say the whole time. There's no one IP that I'm obsessed with. I try to keep tabs and stay up to date with a select few, I generally enjoy a bit larger number of them, but I always laser focus on the aspects of each one that work for me. There's one fictional universe that I love so much so as to surround myself with it 24/7, fantasise about being transported to it, and so on. I keep my obsessions for the real world. Commercialised Pop Cultue is too much of a fickle mistress for me to be truly invested. It's one of the reasons why I got into 1/6th. Once I get the figure, I feel I can close the chapter and not "worry" about that particular IP any more. The figures I'd want for genuine reasons are much fewer than the ones I'm planning to amass.
I've got my OCD completionism tendencies, but the obsession that is fueled by enjoyment is something I've never had.