Renner is on his way to being the next big thing I think. I thought he was cool in 28 Days Later and loved The Hurt Locker. If those two team up I would be seeing that for sure.
He was also the best part of S.W.A.T. as the bad guy.
That said, I heard from two friends that he was not great in this. Both also said it was way too talky. One friend really didn't like it at all, said it was the same old thing with a new guy. The other said it was entertaining but not great. Both agreed that Norton stole the movie.
I really wanted to see this, but now I'm waiting for bluray/dvd/pay-per-view/cable/free TV. Should go well with the Total Rekall.