The Mandalorian (Star Wars Live Action Series)

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Wait a second...by having the BEST OF THE BEST elite Mandos shooting puny grappling hooks into a giant armored alligator instead of immediately taking to the sky and raining death from above that instantly reframes all of BOBF Boba's tactics as being way more badass. I see what they did there!

AnguishedCourteousCirriped-size_restricted.gif


I mean what would THEY have done if challenged by a locked door? Shoot a rope at it? lol

Also one seismic charge would have taken out all six pirates in one fell swoop.

BOBF Fett >>>>>>> Din Djarin and the elite Mandos

:rock
 
Watched it last night, it was alright but a lot of it felt off in some way which has been gone over several times over the last few pages. I wouldn't go as far to say it was outright bad but I can certainly see why it's ringing alarm bells.
 
This show is a MIRACLE of narrative:lecture

Here we're gonna have to agree to disagree; this season opened with Greef Karga trying to sell Mando a house and convincing him to hang up his armor.

Not writing the show off yet, but like I said my socks will still need motive force across the room next time out.
 
First time you see Grogu pop up in the Naboo fighter bubble screamed bad puppet.

There were a number of spots where Grogu just wasn't very convincing in this ep, which I'm not sure I've really noticed as much in the previous seasons.
It's the same animatronic they've always used, you tripping. He looked great.
 
Here we're gonna have to agree to disagree; this season opened with Greef Karga trying to sell Mando a house and convincing him to hang up his armor.

He really should though. His character arc was already complete. Over two seasons, he grew and changed, learned to care about bigger things than himself, he took his helmet off and realized that the world didn't end. That should have been the end of his devotion to his cult right there.

This new side quest of "skinny dipping in the lake" feels so tacked on and pointless. He doesn't need those people. All he cared about was being a dad to the little guy. The story could have ended with Luke taking him away, if you want the bittersweet emotional ending. It could have ended with them reunited and him zipping away in the N1 if you want the happy ending.

If I were the showrunner, I'd have him pick up the hot mom and her kid from the backwater planet and take them to Navarro where he gets his little plot of land. He takes his armor off, and the four of them live as a family happily ever after.

That would be a boring show, I know. It would only be one episode long and barely make it to 15 minutes. But that's the ending I'd want before Mando gets too old and it's too late for him to ever "settle down."



BUT.........



And then it could end about 30 years in the future. His wife has died. His daughter went off and married some dude. It's just toddler-aged Grogu and feeble old man Mando, sitting quietly on the farm. But, just like in "Unforgiven," Mando is pulled back in for ONE. LAST. JOB.

He goes in the backyard and Grogu force lifts the Beskar armor out of the ground where's it's been buried for decades. He puts it on for one final ride and goes out in a blaze of glory. Grogu cries over his father's body. He always knew this day would come, but he wasn't ready for it. He burns Mando's body on a giant pyre, Darth Vader style while sad music plays. Camera slowly zooms in on his hand.....he's holding the gearshift knob.

THE END.
 
Captain Pedantic (tm) underoos.
Put some damn pants on. Ain't nobody wanna see that!
The cave seemed pretty shallow and the Mando's were intent on getting the foundlings out of the way and to safety, tactically they [snip]
That's a very generous reading of that scene. There was more than one casualty as I recall it, but will have to watch again. My position remains that tactically they didn't have to make a stand there. Literally. They had jetpacks. :ROFLMAO:

I mean whatever, I'll let it go. Let's call it an homage to pulp fantasy and leave those poor multimillionaires F&F alone. Poor little guys. Just out there tryin'.

It's also full of whimsy, which even though I'm more of a miserable git I do like some whimsy in my Star Wars. I do appreciate that some fans do not, so you're mileage may vary.
Whimsy's fine, but you gotta take it easy on that stuff.

The way though that some YouTubers etc, have set on this episode like a pack of ravening curs gleefully declaring that the Mandalorian is over seem a tad premature. I guess we'll see over the coming weeks.
YouTubers gotta YouTube.
 
First time you see Grogu pop up in the Naboo fighter bubble screamed bad puppet.

There were a number of spots where Grogu just wasn't very convincing in this ep, which I'm not sure I've really noticed as much in the previous seasons.
I did notice that as well. Weird.
It's the same animatronic they've always used, you tripping. He looked great.
He didn't look *bad* but something looked off every now and then. It may just be that they're having him do more? I don't know.

If I were the showrunner, I'd have him pick up the hot mom and her kid from the backwater planet and
A few people keep mentioning that woman. They were just two ships passing in the night. Just a garden variety case of What Might Have Been.

She's probably moved on already, it's not like she's sitting around pining for a guy whose face she's never seen much less *ahem* .. anyway -- life goes on. It's a big galaxy -- forget her!
 
He really should though. His character arc was already complete. Over two seasons, he grew and changed, learned to care about bigger things than himself, he took his helmet off and realized that the world didn't end. That should have been the end of his devotion to his cult right there.

This new side quest of "skinny dipping in the lake" feels so tacked on and pointless. He doesn't need those people. All he cared about was being a dad to the little guy. The story could have ended with Luke taking him away, if you want the bittersweet emotional ending. It could have ended with them reunited and him zipping away in the N1 if you want the happy ending.

If I were the showrunner, I'd have him pick up the hot mom and her kid from the backwater planet and take them to Navarro where he gets his little plot of land. He takes his armor off, and the four of them live as a family happily ever after.

BOOOOOORRRIIING no offense but that would be boring as hell. Why take this soaring eagle, clip his wings and stuff him into a cage of domesticity?! Why would he settle for Basic B!tch, he needs a wife who is his equal. Sorgan mommy aint his equal.

Meanwhile BoKatan hates herself for loving him. Now there is a wife in which a man could feel the pride of conquest. (Okay, consensual conquest.)

I will agree that the end of season two was almost certainly intended as the close of the show. And I could have lived with that. But I am good with his taking the throne of Mandalore.

He DOES need "those people." They are his family and his kindred. He will have to prove himself to them. He has been alone all his life. He needs and wants his proper place among the clans. On Sorgan he said he does not belong among them. And he was right. He belongs with his own kind.

And then it could end about 30 years in the future. His wife has died. His daughter went off and married some dude. It's just toddler-aged Grogu and feeble old man Mando, sitting quietly on the farm. But, just like in "Unforgiven," Mando is pulled back in for ONE. LAST. JOB.

He goes in the backyard and Grogu force lifts the Beskar armor out of the ground where's it's been buried for decades. He puts it on for one final ride and goes out in a blaze of glory. Grogu cries over his father's body. He always knew this day would come, but he wasn't ready for it. He burns Mando's body on a giant pyre, Darth Vader style while sad music plays. Camera slowly zooms in on his hand.....he's holding the gearshift knob.

THE END.

That is way way way WAY too hardcore for Disney ever to show. But everyone knows a version of it will happen. Outliving all those whom he loves is the curse of a species like Grogu's.
 
Rewatched the S3 premiere again with a friend who is not a hardcore fan. He looked at me when it was over and said "Well, they got two good seasons out of it". Indeed.

Sometimes watching something over again can make it better. So not the case here. They have GOT to turn this around next week. It was even worse the second time.
 
Im hereby predicting that Din and Bo are going to end up ruling Mandalore together, even if not this season since Favreau seems to have not much of an idea where he wants this series to go. They will have to settle their differences first of course.

I dont know that Bo will physically bear children, due to her age and due to inclination - she is a warrior, not the nursery type. But, adoption. And this is Star Wars, exogenesis is a thing here. We'll see what happens, I've been wrong before.


My best guess, if the show keeps following the kind of themes used often by Kurosawa, that it will be the Armorer who ends up as the future leader of the Mandalorians.

Bo Katan is scheming and manipulative and seems to do a lousy job of being scheming and manipulative.

I may be in the minority, but I still love this show. Yes, it's basically Fallout 3 half the time. Mando goes on side quests and trials by fire to go after the main quest to finish the level. Is it a great Star Wars show? That's up for debate. But is it good at homage to old school Samurai movies? I'd say Yes. But I'm a sucker for old school Samurai flicks.

I love Mando and Grogu in the same way I love Lone Wolf And Cub. Grogu is Cub, but just with more merchandising potential.

It's kind of bizarre. The Last Of Us is a video game turned into a TV show. Mandalorian is like a TV show turned into a video game. At this point, I'm expecting Mando to show up at Rivet City to look for that last bobblehead. But I still love it anyway.

This show is fluffly and schmaltzy like The West Wing was fluffy and schmaltzy. It has that kind of fable like tone. But I can see how others won't like it.
 
By brunch a-dev be like…

View attachment 626319

Speaking of cats.

Long ago, a guy I used to be friends with had a son, who was about 7-8 years old back then. And he had a cat that he inherited from his sister. Mean cat. So in the kitchen, the little boy and the cat were going at it or something. The cat scratched at the kid with it's claw. And he got some meat at least on the hand or arm. Then the kid did a snapping punch and punched the cat in the face. Like a Bruce Lee type of lightening strike. Then the kid and the cat just glared at each other.

Now I love animals. I really do. Am I a cat person? No, not a cat person. But I also understand that some crazy mean cat can actually do some real damage to a little kid. So I thought to myself, "If this cat lunges at this kid again, I might actually have to suplex this cat" Or do the People's Elbow, like The Rock. Something.

Then I thought, what if I have to drive this kid to the hospital, if they fight, and some doctor or some nurses asks me what happened and what happened to the cat. And I say I had to suplex the cat. Then they go into hysterics because they are some kind of wacked out furry activist type. Then I have to start doing some Bruce Lee snap punches to the face to get the kid out of there.

So here's the thing, if I am being fair. The guy I used to be friends with, his son was a little punk. I wouldn't say he was a bad seed kind of kid, like a future Damien from The Omen. But he was definitely a little punk. And this cat should have been cast in Mean Girls, as the meanest of mean. Also a punk. And so I had to wonder if I was essentially watching two little punks find some kind of begrudging mutual respect for each other.

So I'm actually thankful. That the cat didn't go full Logan, and shank the kid in the throat with it's claws. Of course it was interesting that when the cat got punched in the face, that it had this expression like "Why did you do that for?"

And that's why I never got married. Because everyone I know who got married and knew them long enough had that situation. That "look" Like they did something vile or ruthless or just plain mean and then wondered why the other person filed for divorce or kicked them out or separated or moved out, etc, etc. "Why did you do that for?"

Do I ever say "What did you do that for?" Really only in one instance. When people send a Xmas card, and inside it is a printout with an itemized list of what the family has achieved that year. We just bought a new house! Junior did great in the 4th grade! I won the official Scott Tenorman Chili Cookoff! And I think to myself, why did you send this to me? This canned photo op in a picture where this nuclear family is grinning like Dirk Diggler on coke. Why did you send me this updated resume style Xmas card / letter / checklist? What did you do that for?

Is the Mandalorian a cat person? Or a dog person? Would he suplex a cat to save Grogu?

Maybe that's how Mandalore got wiped out. Maybe Bo Katan sent a Xmas card with this arrogant schmaltzy checklist update, and then someone like Moff Gideon said, 'What did you do that for? Let's carpet bomb that place!'

What if Mando sent an update Xmas card to people? And talked about how he registered on Plenty Of Fish. And the struggles of dating as a single dad who is also a bounty hunter who likes long walks on the beach. Well endless sand dunes of Tattooine. And he says, "Please no cat people. Also no Sullustians. Thanks." If I was Sullustian, I might be offended. This guy will suck face with a smoker, but not a bona fide high value charming Sullustian?

What were we all talking about again?
 
Back
Top