I have not read any real data on the amount of protein the body can absorb at any given time. I have noticed any more that 2 scoops for me and it can irritate my tummy. People that IF eat all of their protein in as little as 4 hours from start to finish and take in up to 50-70g/sitting.
Yeah, it's a hotly debated topic. Alan Aragon says:
Based on the available evidence, it’s false to assume that the body can only use a certain amount of protein per meal. Studies examining short-term effects have provided hints towards what might be an optimal protein dose for maximizing anabolism, but trials drawn out over longer periods haven’t supported this idea. So, is there a limit to how much protein per meal can be effectively used? Yes there is, but this limit is likely similar to the amount that’s maximally effective in an entire day. What’s the most protein that the body can effectively use in an entire day? The short answer is, a lot more than 20-30 g. --Alan Aragon
The reality is that protein = calories, so if you're trying to get lean, you want to ensure that you're having enough protein in your day but also ensuring you don't have more calories going in than going out.
If you're doing resistance training and want to build muscle and burn some fat on the way, I'd aim to get in 2.5g - 3g of protein per kg of bodyweight per day. If you have to dump calories from somewhere else to accommodate this, then I'd do so.
Creatine is a supplement that is absorbed through the bones, it's just a matter of taking it for a period of time.
Don't believe all this magazine crap about post, pre, perfect timing. It's all a matter of the body being well feed and rested in order to do the work in the gym or whatever training you are doing.
Through the bones???!!! Please link me a resource that backs that up and educate me. My understanding, based on reading the works of sports scientists such as Dr Michael Colgan is that Creatine is stored in the muscles, with excess in other body areas like the brain. It's absorbed into your muscles via your blood via your digestive system - like everything else!
Calcium, however, is absorbed by your bones.
And, timing comes into play for maximising anabolic reaction in the body. If you're going to get really serious, as you'd know being able to go NPC, then you are of course going to time your meals and nutrient intakes in line with your daily training and sleep patterns.
If you're just hitting the gym to lift some weights, then maybe it's not so important - but surely everyone wants to maximise the results of their efforts?
Definitely well fed, as in clean food dense with nutrients, and well rested in terms of lots of sleep (sleep is when the magic happens).
It's the casein in dairy products which whey has a lot of. See the movie forks over knifes on hulu. In the end its my anyones choice to buy what they wish. I was just trying to put it out there as I do with my customers. I don't tell them what to buy. Its there choice. But hey whey is by far the best seller.
Both whey and casein are proteins derived from milk.. but other than that they are completely different.
Maybe you are talking about from a blend? But Whey Protein Isolate is exactly that. Casein is casein. A protein blend might have casein with WPI and WPC... but whey is whey. I guess it's possible to have some cross-contamination during a manufacturing process, but typically WPI is a highly refined and filtered product that extracts the isolate and only the isolate from the milk protein base. So if you were extremely allergic to milk, go veg - otherwise...
But even staunch paleo/primalists, such as Mark Sisson, who don't drink milk or eat cheese recommend whey proteins as the refinement kills the milk elements.
So no benefits at all when using these products post workout? Or just no benefit on the timing of when you take it?
Everyone has a different opinion. I personally train in the morning and I supplement Creatine, Protein and BCAAs.
I take creatine and protein pre-workout, BCAAs during my workout and protein with a little dextrose immediately after training.
Then I will space out further protein intake throughout the day attempting to get as much of it as possible from real food.
This has worked really well for me and I started this structure based on advice from a mate (who is 2 x Jnr INBA Olympia and Mr Australia)... he absolutely walks the walk - and I place a lot of trust in what he says.
Hope that helps!