Which do you think is better? The Lord of the Rings or Nolan's Batman.

[CelticPredator]

Then i'd understand because the director may have been friends with the person, and when he died, it wasn't easy to get over.

 

[crows]

Then i'd understand because the director may have been friends with the person, and when he died, it wasn't easy to get over.

well the movie is done and people understand I guess but like people were saying about Cars 2, a simple mention would have been okay.

 

[jye4ever]

Joker > Sauron

Flass > Orcs

Bat Back Up > Ghost Back Up

Tumbler > Elephants

Alfred > Gandalf

Harvey Dent > Boromir

Lau > Grima Wormtongue

Clowns > Ringwraiths

Batpod > Horses

Fox > Elrond

Gotham > Minis Tirith

Batcave > Shire

Falafel > Weed

LOS > Urak Hai

Ras > Saruman

Gordon > Aragorn

Catwoman > Arwen

Bat Signal > Gandalfs Staff

Bane > Witch King

Talia's death > Sauron's death

Rachel TDK > Gimli

Nolan > Peter Jackson

Bob Kane > JRR Tolkien

Batman > LOTR

So Josh, you wouldn't be related to anyone in the CIA would you.

 

[cerealkeller]

The Fellowship Of the Ring is better than Batman Begins and LOTR.

I love Fellowship. I can watch that any day. Two Towers I am sorry is freaking boring. Until the battle of Helm's Deep, it just feels like I am watching people either walking or getting introduced to characters I find annoying (mainly Aowen). Or watching slo mo Aragorn and Arwen talking. Blah. ROTK is really good, but LOTR peaked with it's first film.

So again I vote Batman. Now SW OT is no contest. That trumps everything. Better characters, better story, way more fun.

 

[intothevoid]

Joker > Sauron

Flass > Orcs

Bat Back Up > Ghost Back Up

Tumbler > Elephants

Alfred > Gandalf

Harvey Dent > Boromir

Lau > Grima Wormtongue

Clowns > Ringwraiths

Batpod > Horses

Fox > Elrond

Gotham > Minis Tirith

Batcave > Shire

Falafel > Weed

LOS > Urak Hai

Ras > Saruman

Gordon > Aragorn

Catwoman > Arwen

Bat Signal > Gandalfs Staff

Bane > Witch King

Talia's death > Sauron's death

Rachel TDK > Gimli

Nolan > Peter Jackson

Bob Kane > JRR Tolkien

Batman > LOTR

So Josh, you wouldn't be related to anyone in the CIA would you.

 

[Lejuan]

Batman's silly voice alone places Nolan's trilogy a distant second.

 

[Uncanny Web-Slinger]

Batman's silly voice alone places Nolan's trilogy a distant second.

Wgattarutalnknbowght ??

 

[ironwez20]

Where's da trigrrrrrrrr

 

[Deedzy]

Odd thing is, Id say the LOTR films are overall better, but I'll rewatch the Batman films more often....

Thats because you have to set aside an entire day to watch a LOTR movie! I mean the blu-ray editions are like 4 hours long

On topic, lord of the rings any day. I like Nolans Batman but Bales Batman voice frackin' cracks me up everytime, it just seems to get more OTT with each installment

 

[The Josh]

Joker > Sauron

Flass > Orcs

Bat Back Up > Ghost Back Up

Tumbler > Elephants

Alfred > Gandalf

Harvey Dent > Boromir

Lau > Grima Wormtongue

Clowns > Ringwraiths

Batpod > Horses

Fox > Elrond

Gotham > Minis Tirith

Batcave > Shire

Falafel > Weed

LOS > Urak Hai

Ras > Saruman

Gordon > Aragorn

Catwoman > Arwen

Bat Signal > Gandalfs Staff

Bane > Witch King

Talia's death > Sauron's death

Rachel TDK > Gimli

Nolan > Peter Jackson

Bob Kane > JRR Tolkien

Batman > LOTR

So Josh, you wouldn't be related to anyone in the CIA would you.

I was more thinking you needed to worry about the DEA.

 

[DiFabio]

• Flass > Orcs
  
• Alfred > Gandalf
  
• Harvey Dent > Boromir
  
• LOS > Urak Hai
  
• Rachel TDK > Gimli
  
• Nolan > Peter Jackson
  
• Bob Kane > JRR Tolkien

These things . . . are not true.


Especially Boromir and Harvey Dent. Boromir's fall is 10x better than Dent's and he actually redeems himself.



LOS > Uruk Hai? WUT?

 

[DiFabio]

I love Fellowship. I can watch that any day. Two Towers I am sorry is freaking boring. Until the battle of Helm's Deep, it just feels like I am watching people either walking or getting introduced to characters I find annoying (mainly Aowen). Or watching slo mo Aragorn and Arwen talking. Blah. ROTK is really good, but LOTR peaked with it's first film.

Yep, agreed.

The Fellowship of the Ring is my favorite, especially the extended version. From the Shire to Amon Hen, it's all great and has a nice flow of pace.

I like the Two Towers but the tree/Ent stuff does take it's toll on me as does the Aragorn and Arwen love fest. It's fine up until Merry and Pippin go into Fangorn forest. The good outweigs the bad though. The highlights for me are Helms Deep, the opening with the Balrog fight, Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli tracking the Uruk-Hai who have captured Merry and Pippin, the Warg fight, most scenes with Saruman, King Theoden, and a good bit of the Frodo, Sam, Gollum and Faramir scenes.

Return of the King is also great, but it's just too grandiose and too long for my tastes. They linger way too long on the climax and it just seems over dramatic. It's like Peter Jackson and the cast and crew didn't want to leave.

But yeah, while they're all great, the Fellowship is definitely my favorite.

 

[Jokes & Bats]

Joker > Sauron

Flass > Orcs

Bat Back Up > Ghost Back Up

Tumbler > Elephants

Alfred > Gandalf

Harvey Dent > Boromir

Lau > Grima Wormtongue

Clowns > Ringwraiths

Batpod > Horses

Fox > Elrond

Gotham > Minis Tirith

Batcave > Shire

Falafel > Weed

LOS > Urak Hai

Ras > Saruman

Gordon > Aragorn

Catwoman > Arwen

Bat Signal > Gandalfs Staff

Bane > Witch King

Talia's death > Sauron's death

Rachel TDK > Gimli

Nolan > Peter Jackson

Bob Kane > JRR Tolkien

Batman > LOTR

Erm..............no.

 

[carbo-fation]

Joker > Sauron

Flass > Orcs

Bat Back Up > Ghost Back Up

Tumbler > Elephants

Alfred > Gandalf

Harvey Dent > Boromir

Lau > Grima Wormtongue

Clowns > Ringwraiths

Batpod > Horses

Fox > Elrond

Gotham > Minis Tirith

Batcave > Shire

Falafel > Weed

LOS > Urak Hai

Ras > Saruman

Gordon > Aragorn

Catwoman > Arwen

Bat Signal > Gandalfs Staff

Bane > Witch King

Talia's death > Sauron's death

Rachel TDK > Gimli

Nolan > Peter Jackson

Bob Kane > JRR Tolkien

Batman > LOTR

So Josh, you wouldn't be related to anyone in the CIA would you.

I call BS on this list. Everyone knows falafel taste like ****! YOu've lost credibility JyeFab!

 

[thenammagazine]

Notice Jye intentionally left out the Hobbits and Thalia's death scene. Included, Batman fails.

 

[jye4ever]

I was more thinking you needed to worry about the DEA.

These things . . . are not true.


Especially Boromir and Harvey Dent. Boromir's fall is 10x better than Dent's and he actually redeems himself.



LOS > Uruk Hai? WUT?

If only Saruman and hiz bros had said: "We iz da leeeghue awf uruk hai"

Yep, agreed.

The Fellowship of the Ring is my favorite, especially the extended version. From the Shire to Amon Hen, it's all great and has a nice flow of pace.

I like the Two Towers but the tree/Ent stuff does take it's toll on me as does the Aragorn and Arwen love fest. It's fine up until Merry and Pippin go into Fangorn forest. The good outweigs the bad though. The highlights for me are Helms Deep, the opening with the Balrog fight, Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli tracking the Uruk-Hai who have captured Merry and Pippin, the Warg fight, most scenes with Saruman, King Theoden, and a good bit of the Frodo, Sam, Gollum and Faramir scenes.

Return of the King is also great, but it's just too grandiose and too long for my tastes. They linger way too long on the climax and it just seems over dramatic. It's like Peter Jackson and the cast and crew didn't want to leave.

But yeah, while they're all great, the Fellowship is definitely my favorite.

I call BS on this list. Everyone knows falafel taste like ****! YOu've lost credibility JyeFab!

No, you just love weed.

Notice Jye intentionally left out the Hobbits and Thalia's death scene. Included, Batman fails.

 

[Dark_Knight_89]

Have to go with The Lord of the Rings... Simply a perfect movie Trilogy and on par with Star Wars

 

[The Josh]

None of these are boring to me. There are bits I'm not big on or I don't like but really those are few over the course of the three films. Some of what I've seen mentioned as being "meh" are parts hat help add depth to the story. For me this is why these three films are better than any trilogy is because the depth provided by Tolkien trumps all.

 

[jye4ever]

While i'm excited for the Hobbit, for me it's somewhat anticlimatic that the LOTR were made first.

The biggest emotional impact has occurred already, the destruction of the ring.

While Hobbit will be fun and exciting, nothing will provide me that emotional ending.

 

[The Ween]

While i'm excited for the Hobbit, for me it's somewhat anticlimatic that the LOTR were made first.

The biggest emotional impact has occurred already, the destruction of the ring.

While Hobbit will be fun and exciting, nothing will provide me that emotional ending.

You don't know what Jackson has in store for us.

Hmmmm......I'm surprised you have started an Avengers poll of some sort.