Like I said, my issue with it is knowing it wasn't the plan from the start of Episode I and that it got thought of in the Ep3 process when suddenly things had to all be tied up, but that's my feeling on the reason for it being there. As far as it being there in the film, I feel like most, that Neeson should be thrown in because it feels only half executed instead of given 100%, and perhaps seeing it fully carried out would change my feelings about it's conception.
Well, even if it was just a way to tie things up in ROTS they did a nice job of doing so. Even if he's never put in it I feel the line is what its supposed to be after seeing ROTS and reading the ROTS novel.
For me, that's half the fun...taking something from these movies that may seem a little vague on the surface, and putting your own interpretation on it to give it a different context. That's why that line works as an opening for Qui-Gon's "next step" for me...
No wrong or right here...with anyone's take on it.
I agree. I love taking whats said vaguley in the movies and trying to interpret or tie it in with other stuff from the movies/books.
That's why I love the fact that the PT was made, opens up your ability to experience the OT in a whole new way.
It really does for me at least.