X-Men: Days of Future Past

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Well, putting our own preferences aside, I really don't see an X-franchise without Wolverine. He's their equivalent of Spider-Man or Batman. So, if you accept that, what would you prefer--a total reboot, or keeping the First Class guys, and adding a new Wolvie? My preference is the latter, because the First Class guys are great for the most part.

This right here!

The FC crew can definitely carry the franchise. Cast a new Wolverine along with younger characters from the old trilogy and we pretty much have a reboot. The cast is way too talented to just get rid of.


On the topic of a short Wolverine, he doesn’t have to be 5’3 on the dot, but a shorter actor with a more compact body definitely works for me. I’m not saying I want Hugh replaced, but when he inevitably does leave the role, I think Tom Hardy would be perfect to take over. He certainly isn’t ugly, and he has that compact, Mike Tyson like build that fans have been waiting to see from Wolverine. Right now, I can’t think of a better actor for the role. When the recast happens, I certainly don’t want another tall, lanky actor to take the role.
 
Last edited:
It must not be that big of a deal if people have been so accepting of Jackman's Wolverine for the past 10+ years.

You do realize if Wolverine was 5'3" he'd be less than a foot taller than Peter Dinklage, right?

Why do you feel that Wolverine needs to be tall? You got something against short people? :lol
 
What O fond stupid about tall wolverine's is that the nickname doesnt entirely work anymore. Real wolverine's are fairly small animals. Ive always seen wolverine as the superhero equivalent of a taz devil, he doesn't look insanely intimidating, but **** me he's one massiv ball of claws in your face.

Wolverine's short height gives him the aspect of being the underdog, which fits so well with being an nti-hero.

Right now he's neither.
 
Short wolverine works in comics but on screen with real people it will look dumb.

Why!?:lol Tom Cruise is a massive action star, he's short. Why would it be dumb, that's so silly to say based on somebody's height, we're not talking mini-me here.:lol Wolverine would be awesome if he had about Hardy's posture from Warrior, with an appropriate yellow+blue or brown outfit.
 
ask the hobbit people if they thought it was dumb
Not sure if serious. That is like the worst possible comparison.

Yes, if you put a Hobbit with mutton chops, a cigar and metal claws next to a cast of normal-sized people in a serious role, in a movie unrelated to Middle Earth...it will look very, very dumb.
 
What O fond stupid about tall wolverine's is that the nickname doesnt entirely work anymore. Real wolverine's are fairly small animals. Ive always seen wolverine as the superhero equivalent of a taz devil, he doesn't look insanely intimidating, but **** me he's one massiv ball of claws in your face.

Wolverine's short height gives him the aspect of being the underdog, which fits so well with being an nti-hero.

Right now he's neither.

Why!?:lol Tom Cruise is a massive action star, he's short. Why would it be dumb, that's so silly to say based on somebody's height, we're not talking mini-me here.:lol Wolverine would be awesome if he had about Hardy's posture from Warrior, with an appropriate yellow+blue or brown outfit.
:exactly: :goodpost: :goodpost: :goodpost:
 
Short is fine, but yes, Gaspar was talking mini-me. Tom Cruise is apparently 5'7". That's short for a man, but not dwarfism short.
 
This screams Wolverine to me

10298785_669138153123518_4685541129764446927_n.jpg
 
Lol, I just saw Hugh, Michael and James at the Graham Norton Show, **** me there's so really bizarre creepy fan fiction about Michael and James man, the bloody hell!?

To quote Michael Cera "Super gay."

Anyway, uhm, that picture screams Hugh's Wolverine, but not comic book wolverine. First of all because imo Wolverine should hunch over more as he's a leaper, he will jump you (or get thrown), tall people just can't get away with that fluent behaviour as good. Secondly, Hugh never wears the mask, he just doesn't, that's a massive permanent notch down for me because Wolverine, to me, is as tied to his mask as Captain America is. Yes he removes it, but it IS his signature uniform.

The whole thing about him being small is that it's a psychological effect that makes him extra aggressive, because he always want s to take on guys bigger than him. That's how he started in the Hulk, that's how his rivalry with Sabretooth plays out. Wolverine is THE underdog that just won't ****ing stop. He looks for the biggest guy and just starts scratchin him all the way down to his level.

THIS screams wolverine:
wolverine-20090430022852186-000.jpg


And as much as I like Hugh, both his size and the lack of a costume has never rendered him able to truly be like that. He almost always outsizes his opponent, he never wears a mask, so he never has the white ghostly eyes coming at you.

Hugh was a great revolution in taking CB characters seriously, he's a great guy, and he nails the pain and rage, the psychology of wolverine very well, but from a visual point of view, he's never been wolverine to me. It's too much of a core aspect of the character to me that Wolverine always looks up, always bites off more than he can chew, but because of his sick healing factor, he remains standing anyway.

For those who know Dragonball Z Wolverine is like Vegeta to me, he gets mocked, he gets used, he gets manipulated, he rarely engages an opponent weaker than him, and yet always wants to fight before talking. And with Vegeta it's that same thing that he's smaller than almost everyone else that makes the character visually work. Everyone would be pissed if they were that small. Oh and for the record, I'm 6'6.

That Wolverine I've never seen in cinemas, not really. Glimpses in the first two x-men at best.

I guess Wolverin 2013 had some good aspects in that regard, I will say that. But that's a solo film. I'm tired of him having to be the leader.
 
Back
Top