Zack Snyder's Rebel Moon

[abake]

https://nypost.com/2016/03/30/batman-v-superman-is-too-smart-for-marvel-fans/

That's a surprisingly interesting read.

 

[ironwez20]

Pretending your opinions are facts again I see.

We are still talking about it because fans are divided and have resolute opinions that neither side wants to drop. Granted, the division is higher on one end but it's still there. Very few movies, if any, that are "bad" have arguments that raged this long after they came and went. Surely there is a reason for that.
I had a look on here at superhero movies that weren't loved by all to see what amount of discussions went on.

Iron Man 3: Lasted 16 months after release.
The Amazing Spider-Man 2: Lasted 10 months after release.
Man of Steel: Lasted 7 years after release
BvS: Lasted 4 years after release (see if you can guess who the last post was by)
Wonder Woman 1984: Lasted 18 months after release (another cameo by you)

There are very few if any arguments back and forth over over TASM 2 in the Amazing Spider-Man 2 [NWH] figure thread. Same with Wonder Woman 1984 and that figure.
Why is that do you think?

Maybe there is something to it.

https://nypost.com/2016/03/30/batman-v-superman-is-too-smart-for-marvel-fans/

wtf are you talking about? . Of course they do! Batman vs robin is still talked about to this day, tasm2 is still talked about to this day. And are you really basing the world’s view discussion on this message board that’s very niche? Come on really?
The reason that discussion went on is cause people had high hopes for it and the directors cut. It’s not cause anyone thought it was a deep movie that needed to be studied .
Also I’m sure the bvs movie lasted thst long cause of the back and forth similar to here. People telling others that the movie was deeper than it was.

So by your logic Batman and Robin is a masterpiece cause it’s still talked about to this day or films like the last Jedi which had a waaaaaaay bigger discussion than bvs are great movies cause they are still being discussed?

Again we only are talking about cause the whole “deconstructed” argument in this case we are saying it sucks or atleast I am.

And lol at that article.

So we don’t get Batman vs Superman you had to have been a marvel fan ? Yea what a tired argument. Not liking the movie has nothing to do with being marvel fan.

Try again please

 

[The Buffinator]

Maybe there is something to it.

https://nypost.com/2016/03/30/batman-v-superman-is-too-smart-for-marvel-fans/

Wow, dredging up an 8 year old pro-BvS column by a guy who doesn't like Marvel movies (and apparently doesn't think movies based on comic book heroes should be fun lol) to support your view? And it's a guy who worked at that bastion of journalistic integrity The New York Post? This screams of desperation my friend. But that guy was right in saying BvS was the opposite of mindless entertainment. It's definitely neither mindless nor entertaining.

 

[T8OO]

wtf are you talking about? . Of course they do! Batman vs robin is still talked about to this day, tasm2 is still talked about to this day. And are you really basing the world’s view discussion on this message board that’s very niche? Come on really?
The reason that discussion went on is cause people had high hopes for it and the directors cut. It’s not cause anyone thought it was a deep movie that needed to be studied .
Also I’m sure the bvs movie lasted thst long cause of the back and forth similar to here. People telling others that the movie was deeper than it was.

So by your logic Batman and Robin is a masterpiece cause it’s still talked about to this day or films like the last Jedi which had a waaaaaaay bigger discussion than bvs are great movies cause they are still being discussed?

Again we only are talking about cause the whole “deconstructed” argument in this case we are saying it sucks or atleast I am.

And lol at that article.

So we don’t get Batman vs Superman you had to have been a marvel fan ? Yea what a tired argument. Not liking the movie has nothing to do with being marvel fan.

Try again please

I am not saying B&R or The Last Jedi are not talked about. Look at the examples, by comparison nearly everything else is lower. The Last Jedi is lower than both MoS and BvS. I'm asking why that is. I'm taking easy to find information from here to show something.
You aren't doing that, you are saying Martha + Neck Snap + Rushed compared to MCU so it's bad.

I'd like it if you tried just once.

 

[T8OO]

Wow, dredging up an 8 year old pro-BvS column by a guy who doesn't like Marvel movies (and apparently doesn't think movies based on comic book heroes should be fun lol) to support your view? And it's a guy who worked at that bastion of journalistic integrity The New York Post? This screams of desperation my friend. But that guy was right in saying BvS was the opposite of mindless entertainment. It's definitely neither mindless nor entertaining.

Desperation is such a strange term to be used in such discussions. I'm adding information I come across to support my point. I've seen people write essays and post examples on here for the opposite and no one brings up them being desperate.

You're right it isn't mindless, that is what I'm trying to get across. People may not find it entertaining but mindless it isn't.

 

[ironwez20]

I am not saying B&R or The Last Jedi are not talked about. Look at the examples, by comparison nearly everything else is lower. The Last Jedi is lower than both MoS and BvS. I'm asking why that is. I'm taking easy to find information from here to show something.
You aren't doing that, you are saying Martha + Neck Snap + Rushed compared to MCU so it's bad.

I'd like it if you tried just once.

No it’s not there just on here. Get out your bubble. And please tell me what bvs is known for by the GA besides save Martha . I’ll wait. And the mcu had build up and made various billion dollar films.
Maybe you should try harder. Your arguments like most Snyder fans are never good

 

[Sassafras]

Finally got around to watching it. Liked it better than S1 - because what's not to like IMO if u like good 'ol fantasy and sci-fi. Tropey trope trope trope loaded with tropes and tried so hard to be epic and meaningful etc. They tried. It was perfectly inoffensive except for some eyerolls over the Last of the Mohicans guy with the hatchetsand great hair.

and the over the top end fight - John Wick this is not. The robot still looks kinda cool.

Look, I've seen episodes of Star Trek I've thought about years later (like, Picard). Gets an A for sincere effort tho. No, more sex and violence isn't gonna help 'coz TROPES but bein' a fantasy fan - it's no worse than the other "motley band of adventurers gets together to save McGuffin/sacred child" I've read over the years. Better than that (*&^% Witcher prequel or that Jupiter whatever movie. At least it wasn't magical teenagers. Rating = "eh".

 

[T8OO]

No it’s not there just on here. Get out your bubble. And please tell me what bvs is known for by the GA besides save Martha . I’ll wait. And the mcu had build up and made various billion dollar films.
Maybe you should try harder. Your arguments like most Snyder fans are never good

How convenient for you that it's just on here. I'd be happy to look at it if you want to bring any information to back that up.

For the GA my guess would be Batman and Superman going against each other, similar to if you asked them about Civil War. It's the GA, they don't concern themselves with movies once they've been and gone. They certainly don't get hung up for 8 years on a name being said.

 

[Wor-Gar]

What is Rebel Moon 3 going to be about?

 

[Random_Retard]

What is Rebel Moon 3 going to be about?

Nothing. 'cause I'm pretty sure it won't ever happen...

 

[T8OO]

What is Rebel Moon 3 going to be about?

My guess:

Spoiler

Finding the Princess with the surviving Rebels

 

[T8OO]

Nothing. 'cause I'm pretty sure it won't ever happen...

Why is that?

 

[ironwez20]

How convenient for you that it's just on here. I'd be happy to look at it if you want to bring any information to back that up.

For the GA my guess would be Batman and Superman going against each other, similar to if you asked them about Civil War. It's the GA, they don't concern themselves with movies once they've been and gone. They certainly don't get hung up for 8 years on a name being said.

What’s on here? And nope cause you know why? They barely fought? Which movie made more money and had a bigger impact on pop culture tho?

It’s not the one with the two most iconic characters in the superhero fandom . And who’s getting hung up? Do you read? The whole reason we are having this discussion is cause of you and alatar saying how we didn’t get the deconstruction of Batman and Superman. It’s not cause we are thinking fondly of it.

You literally just pushed the narrative that marvel fans didn’t get it cause it was to smart for them which is probably the silliest argument I’ve ever heard of.

Yea marvel fans didn’t like Batman and Robin cause they didn’t understand the huge deep dive the bat credit card represents. That’s how you sound

 

[T8OO]

What’s on here? And nope cause you know why? They barely fought? Which movie made more money and had a bigger impact on pop culture tho?

It’s not the one with the two most iconic characters in the superhero fandom . And who’s getting hung up? Do you read? The whole reason we are having this discussion is cause of you and alatar saying how we didn’t get the deconstruction of Batman and Superman. It’s not cause we are thinking fondly of it.

You literally just pushed the narrative that marvel fans didn’t get it cause it was to smart for them which is probably the silliest argument I’ve ever heard of.

Yea marvel fans didn’t like Batman and Robin cause they didn’t understand the huge deep dive the bat credit card represents. That’s how you sound

So again, bringing absolutely no tangible information.

Superhero fandom isn't the GA.

 

[The Buffinator]

Desperation is such a strange term to be used in such discussions. I'm adding information I come across to support my point. I've seen people write essays and post examples on here for the opposite and no one brings up them being desperate.

You're right it isn't mindless, that is what I'm trying to get across. People may not find it entertaining but mindless it isn't.

Yeah, I was just poking fun with the desperation comment given the age of the column lol. All good.

 

[ironwez20]

So again, bringing absolutely no tangible information.

Superhero fandom isn't the GA.

Bro you said earlier that the reason bvs is relevant is cause we are talking about on here after all these years tho . Lmao . The back tracking is crazy .

 

[Wor-Gar]

they didn’t understand the huge deep dive the bat credit card represents.

That's deconstruction at its best.

It totally questions how superheroes pay for things. Do they steal?

It addresses the concept of a superhero wallet.

It addresses a long-held concern: do superhero outfits have pockets?

All in one shot. Brilliance!

 

[ironwez20]

That's deconstruction at its best.

It totally questions how superheroes pay for things. Do they steal?

It addresses the concept of a superhero wallet.

It addresses a long-held concern: do superhero outfits have pockets?

All in one shot. Brilliance!

You have to be some sort of mcu shill to not understand the genius behind the bat credit card

 

[Alatar]

What is Rebel Moon 3 going to be about?

As they said at the end of Part 2, next they 1) find Princess Issa, 2) continue to fight the Imperium.

It’ll be interesting to see the explanation for how Issa still lives. We do see her life energy leave her body when she is killed, though. And she resurrects a dead bird in Part 1 using the same sparkly light. One of the names of the ancient goddess Issa is “Lifegiver.” Maybe her spirit just leaves her body and at some point if it was left alone before whatever is done with corpses by the Imperium her spirit resurrects her slain body?

 

[The Buffinator]

As they said at the end of Part 2, next they 1) find Princess Issa, 2) continue to fight the Imperium.

It’ll be interesting to see the explanation for how Issa still lives. We do see her life energy leave her body when she is killed, though. And she resurrects a dead bird in Part 1 using the same sparkly light. One of the names of the ancient goddess Issa is “Lifegiver.” Maybe her spirit just leaves her body and at some point if it was left alone before whatever is done with corpses by the Imperium her spirit resurrects her slain body?

So this deconstruction will include the resurrection of a decomposed princess?