After their Black Dynamite figure, with rooted afro.
Tell me about it. The man's perfect for it and he'll die before we get it.
Reeves took this from us... Honestly, I want a DaFoe dolly, and I'm unlikely to buy a Goblin, so that would've been my last chance to get him. But apparently he wants to play a Joker in Phoenix's Joker 2, so who knows.
Oh, Skarsgard would've been a perfect, more "classic" Joker. Bright colours, jokes, the whole shebang.
As for Keoghan, he's not a bad actor, but... At the very least I think it's a lock that they'll give him the rejected Ledger look:
It could be cool, I guess. For me, my interest in this trilogy comes mostly from Pattinson and the general Y2K Fincher look. If they keep that in the sequels, and go with a Trent Reznor Joker, I could be intrigued. But I think the world's ready for a more flashy Joker, and this won't be that. The scene in The Batman was downright awful though, and I don't say that lightly.
On the other hand, I am kind of rooting for him as an actor. He's had a pretty rough upbringing (alcoholic heroin parents, 13 different foster homes, the works), so him finding success is a bright spot. And as with most people who make it in the industry and aren't super models, he puts in the work. But I can't see him as the Joker, as his face is too goofy for the lanky, creepy looking Joker. You can't go from Ledger, to Leto and then to Pheonix, until you end up with him.
I am willing to give him the benefit of the doubt at the end of the day. I'd bring up Ledger's casting, but honestly I never much had trouble with it. I saw him as a talented actor with range and a great face, so the whole "lmao, they got the gay cowboy" thing never got to me. For my money, he's just going to look too short next to Pattinson, who's a legit 6'0". Ledger & Bale were nicely paired, come to think of it.