OK... I just received ARAGORN. First, I'll let the fresh-out-of-the-box pictures speak for themselves...
He definitely has that "Huh - what?" expression, no getting around it. Mine also has a strange snarl in the lips.
The hair -- not bad once in scale, but there could be more detail.
The beard -- a bit heavy, and too dark a color. Also, the most distracting thing, its very glossy.
The face -- some detail comes through a rather heavy paint job. The eyebrows on mine are painted lightly enough to look good, if it wasn't for those really bright, large eyes. You can see them clear across the room.
The outfit -- good overall. The tunic is really nice. The pants even have a row of lace-up ties on them -- pretty cool considering you'll never see it. The jacket is somewhat shiny though. The boots are okay, about what we expected.
Overall -- I'm torn; essentially its what everyone feared it would be -- its a 12" figure, not a museum piece or mini PF -- and yet I do find myself liking the figure. I haven't even begun to check out all the accessories but they look great in the box. Covering him in his supplies will definitely help. But I really like the materials used for the overcoat and tunic. The cloak is nice too -- also spotted with mud, a wire in the hood, and in a very dark brown color. The hood is much narrower than the Jedi cloaks and comes to an exceptionally long tip, which I believe is very accurate.
I do think this figure has potential. But I really need to spend some time futzing with this one to make a final decision on whether I keep him and continue with the line.