ooops! That's right.
But didn't they directly say that if "the Emperor knew"... so they hid the kids because of Palpatine, right?
**Beware SPOILERS** Obi-Wan Kenobi Series on Disney+ **Beware SPOILERS**
- Thread starter Popnfresh98
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
ooops! That's right.
But didn't they directly say that if "the Emperor knew"... so they hid the kids because of Palpatine, right?
Actually didn't ROTJ Obi-Wan say that they knew that if the Emperor knew that Anakin had any offspring that they'd be a threat to him so they were kept safely anonymous?
I could be wrong but wasn't he just referring to keeping the twins hidden from Palpatine without any reference to them knowing that Anakin was also alive?
And the bathroom wall doesn't?
''To protect you both from the Emperor you were hidden from your father when you were born. The Emperor knew, as I did, if Anakin were to have any offspring, they would be a threat to him. That is the reason why your sister remains safely anonymous.''
Ah-ha! Very good.
Ah okay, thanks for clarifying. We'll I don't think that's too out of bounds for ROTJ Obi-Wan.
"Well technically you were hidden from your father...inadvertently when we hid you from Palpatine. Years later I learned that he was still alive. So what I told you was true, from a certain point of view."
Old Obi-Wan, at it again. 
I'd like to preface this that I am not a fan of the Inquisitors so far in this show, however....
I do think some form of them is a logical necessity in the Star Wars universe. People in this universe are naturally born with the ability to wield the Force. The Empire would be stupid to forgo either utilizing this to their advantage (like they do with Inquisitors) because these people can end up posing as a threat to the Empire.
That said, I do not like the implementation of the Inquisitors here so far. I agree with you, the design, dialog and acting here are cringe-inducing.
I don't know... the fact that Vader's own children survived without him knowing about them makes me think it is also logical that such a large organization such as the Jedi will always have survivors that are unknown to the Empire even in such a galactic purge. These are trained fighters who know how to survive and avoid detection.
I see using the Force kinda like riding a bike. You may be very good at it now, but your first pedal strokes will be wobbly if you haven't ridden one in over a decade.
Our brains tend to forget things we don't practice.
Even with handwriting. I mean, I grew up all my life learning how to write in school (we have those penmanship classes all the way from pre-school until I graduated high school) and now that pretty much 100% of my job is done paperless via computers, I have difficulty handwriting forms whenever I need to (my wife does this for me now too). I can very well imagine someone being rusty after not using the Force for so long.
I do think some form of them is a logical necessity in the Star Wars universe. People in this universe are naturally born with the ability to wield the Force. The Empire would be stupid to forgo either utilizing this to their advantage (like they do with Inquisitors) because these people can end up posing as a threat to the Empire.
That said, I do not like the implementation of the Inquisitors here so far. I agree with you, the design, dialog and acting here are cringe-inducing.
I don't know... the fact that Vader's own children survived without him knowing about them makes me think it is also logical that such a large organization such as the Jedi will always have survivors that are unknown to the Empire even in such a galactic purge. These are trained fighters who know how to survive and avoid detection.
I see using the Force kinda like riding a bike. You may be very good at it now, but your first pedal strokes will be wobbly if you haven't ridden one in over a decade.
Our brains tend to forget things we don't practice.
Even with handwriting. I mean, I grew up all my life learning how to write in school (we have those penmanship classes all the way from pre-school until I graduated high school) and now that pretty much 100% of my job is done paperless via computers, I have difficulty handwriting forms whenever I need to (my wife does this for me now too
). I can very well imagine someone being rusty after not using the Force for so long.
OK, so here's the QUESTION of the evening --
What is the most blatant and offensive lie or retcon is all the Star Wars movies?
Is it what ESB did to ANH Obi-Wan? The First Lie.
What is the most blatant and offensive lie or retcon is all the Star Wars movies?
Is it what ESB did to ANH Obi-Wan? The First Lie.
Prime Clone
Super Freak
So much for the ol' saying "just like riding a bike"!
That was kinda justifiable. You wouldn't want to hit Luke with the truth about his father first up.
Personally I'm more annoyed how the DS plans weren't "beamed" to the Rebels in RO. Hand-delivery was a cynical device to let Vader cut down some fleet troopers.
But there's plenty of time for OWK to outdo that.
They were though. Jyn literally beamed the plans up to the Rebels from that giant dish on top of the tower.
The writers called out a real conundrum that they realized they were faced with when they studied ANH. Because at the beginning Leia is holding a disc, then Vader says the plans were beamed, then later after that Admiral Motti says they were stolen data tapes. Three different forms of media called out for the same set of plans in one movie.
So their solution was to have Jyn steal a data tape from the vault, then beam the data to the ship, then have it be extracted via disc. Pretty ingenious way to tie up that continuity IMO.
Otomofan
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2009
- Messages
- 5,255
- Reaction score
- 4,124
Luke and Leia being siblings ...hands down. You do not spend two movies LUSTING OVER and even KISSING your own sister!!
Even as a little kid I knew that was a huge load of BS.
Nothing else comes close.
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2014
- Messages
- 13,003
- Reaction score
- 4,493
I'm very disappointed in myself that the old classic phone number on the bathroom wall gag didn't occur to me immediately while watching the show. Talk about a 70s/80s Easter egg.
For a hairy good time call Peli xxx 867 5309.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2014
- Messages
- 13,003
- Reaction score
- 4,493
The existence of Rey Skywalker. Nothing else is close.
Blatant and offensive? In all honesty, besides obsessive SW nerds, who really gives a ****?
100% agree. Absolutely, positively, shark jumping, fridge nuking ridiculous.
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2014
- Messages
- 13,003
- Reaction score
- 4,493
Blatant and offensive? In all honesty, besides obsessive SW nerds, who really gives a ****?
Blatant and offensive? In all honesty, besides obsessive SW nerds, who really gives a ****?
It's just a question, Snoop. You can play or not.
Yeah, the worst is Leia being the "other." That right there derailed the grand Saga that ANH and ESB was building to and SW has been in some degree of damage control ever since. Even if you don't like Rey she's a drop in the bucket that came way late in the game after countless damage had already been done.
But the sins of ROTJ tarnished perfection.
That's why I chuckle at the supposedly high and mighty notion of being an "OT purist." Purist of what? Childhood nostalgia maybe. Because once you include ROTJ you fully admit to eating horse**** and calling it lasagna just like the rest of us, lol.
But the sins of ROTJ tarnished perfection.
That's why I chuckle at the supposedly high and mighty notion of being an "OT purist." Purist of what? Childhood nostalgia maybe. Because once you include ROTJ you fully admit to eating horse**** and calling it lasagna just like the rest of us, lol.
Similar threads
