The pacing was all over the place, the editing was a nightmare and confusing at times with bad transitioning. The music video edition we got can’t possibly have been better than the original Ayer cut. And at times it felt like that. I enjoyed the soundtrack and many songs were befitting of the scenes, but there was too much and it was over done. Like the music was supposed to make up for the lack of characterization. Instead of having scenes were we actually learn about people, just play some cool music that explains their personalities…Lazy writing, but a cheap fix to too many characters and never being able to have the time to tell enough backstory so the viewers give a crap. Just flood em’ with Deathstroke & Harley, since Will Smith & Margot Robbie are the stars after all. The rest of the SS members, other than Diablo, are just filler. Really, they are the only 3 characters needed in this movie. No one else serves any point or plot movement at all. And as for slipknot, I saw that coming a mile away. He gets no intro scene at all and given no explanation why he is there other than an introduction line of “he can climb anything”. He just appears onscreen. Meanwhile we did see what Boomerang did to his partner in his backstories robbery scene, so you knew he was a patsy and a goner the minute their little conversation began. Ok, a guy you never met tells you they’re lying and the bomb in our neck is fake, let’s make a run for it, but you go first…. Bad…..just bad.
I don’t think I ever laughed even once. At least not at what was intended to be funny. I laughed at how bad parts were. Leto as the Joker is just hard to watch. Not as bad as Snyder and Eisenberg’s version of Luthor in BvS, but still bad. This is no Joker I’d ever expect to see. From his look, to the acting and portrayal, it’s just plain bad and cringe worthy. With the bad facial expressions, constant smiling and showing off those terrible teeth, Stevie Wonder head bobbing, bad timing, terrible laugh, and the use of those oh so unnecessary tattoos….. And Harley was polarizing to me too. Some stuff was good, some stuff was bad. I don’t think she really knew what to do with the role. But she gets a pass since this is the first on screen, non animated Harley. So there is nothing to compare her performance too. No benchmark for her performance to strive too to improve upon. It is what it is. Deathstroke was simply Will Smith being Will Smith. Just being the charismatic actor that he is. Not always a good thing depending on the character, but it did work here. Viola Davis was great as Waller as everyone has said. And the guy who played Diablo was great. Everyone else was either here or there, good or bad. But it doesn’t really matter since none of them are onscreen enough to care except for Flagg, and he was just fine.
The Enchantress was a terrible villain choice for this movie. Carla Devigne was horrible. As June Moon she was meh, any one would’ve done fine in the role, as Enchantress there were times she was good, but mostly bad. And why the two looks? First we get the witch Tia Dalma from Pirates of The Caribbean, then we get a more regal looking goddess, then she reverts back again…What?? ….WHY!?? The whole Ghostbusters CGI ending I felt like I was watching her version of Gozer. Bad bad dancing, weaving,or whatever the hell she was supposed to be doing up there. Really gave no backstory to her character at all. The only line giving a clue to her and her CGI brother Incubus’ motivations were the line “We were once worshipped as gods, now they worship technology”. Ok, yeah. Those are some real motivations to destroy the world. Like a spoiled child not getting a new toy to play with. After all, if they long to be worshipped again, doesn’t make much sense to kill everyone or turn them into the worst looking goons I’ve ever seen on screen and just have mindless slaves with nothing to do. Then after showing how powerful she is, she decides to fight them with weapons in hand to hand combat? And no she didn’t lose power cause her brother died, she only needed him till she got her heart back. Cause she respects them?? WTF doe she respect them for? And the big hero shot with Will Smith?? They show she can teleport anywhere and back in the blink of an eye as in the military briefing scene, but she couldn’t get the bomb as it slow mo’d in the air just knowing Deadshot will shoot it? Instead she pretends to be his daughter to confuse him?? WTF? I can go on and on, but most has already been said by others….
So after all that, how can I say I somewhat liked it and it was entertaining?? Because under all that mess I saw on screen, I genuinely believe there was a good movie hidden in there, with bad Letoker and all. There wasn’t enough of him to ever warm up too, the same with all the other members of the SS. Again it was WB/DC and their damage control in response to BvS that ruined this movie. The list of cut scenes show’s there were compelling shots that could’ve made you care more and actually did these characters justice. I would love to see Ayer’s cut before the panic and the trailer people came in and butchered this movie to make it match the “fun” movie their trailer portrayed. Then even further butchering by mending movies A and B into movie C to appease the feedback from the test audiences. Why are these random people more important than the director that this film was entrusted too? That just gave it the kiss of death. I don’t think Snyder and WB/DC understood why BvS failed. Because if they did they never would’ve butchered SS. This IS the movie that needed to be dark, edgy and gritty. A different take on the traditional “Superhero” genre as with Deadpool, border lining on a soft “R” rating due to tone and violence. Their villains, not heroes and you should be made to love hating them due to their decisions and actions, not actually love them because they have “heart”. BvS should’ve been more of an uplifting movie, and SS the depressing movie. I shouldn’t have hated or felt indifferent towards the heroes in BvS, yet loved the villains in SS.
This is a movie that should’ve been a few more down the line, like GotG. Make us want to be vested in their universe first with good movies focusing on the heavy hitters, then introducing us to the “c” list… This is simply DC/WB’s greed in not establishing their universe first. Having no actual plan mapped out for the future. They just want to cash in on their “properties” and not be outdone by Marvel in a cockfight. That’s all these characters seem to be to them. It’s as if they don’t generally care for their creations, they just see the $$ signs they bring with them. Fox has ruined the X-Men, but they didn’t create them so they don’t care. They just payed Marvel to play with them as they see fit. It seems WB is doing the same. They purchased DC years ago, but never integrated them into the family. They didn’t create a new DC movie division like Marvel did, they just took the movie maker WB execs and told them to make comic book movies the same way they handle any other property as a potential script for film.