Magpie 7
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2010
- Messages
- 1,717
- Reaction score
- 1
Kind of like Roger Moore wearing a leather jacket and trainers in A View To A Kill.........
Doctor Who - Spoilers!
- Thread starter Memnoch
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
Kind of like Roger Moore wearing a leather jacket and trainers in A View To A Kill.........
- Joined
- Nov 22, 2008
- Messages
- 2,728
- Reaction score
- 48
I've watched it three times mate. It is one of the best of all time.
Kamandi
Super Freak
I wonder if a 2 billion year old Doctor will officially be cannon going forward?
I don't think so...I mean, it was a 'new' copy each time he arrived in the teleporter. He knew it had been 2 billion years, but it still would've only felt as long as that particular copy had been there (a couple of weeks maybe?).
cmiller99
Super Freak
That's a good point. If he's been going through a loop like that, does he age? Interesting question...
- Joined
- Apr 12, 2013
- Messages
- 6,483
- Reaction score
- 102
Very confusing ep for me. He was teleported inside that confession disk? And then spent 2 billion years punching his way through a wall that lead him to Galifrey? Which was outside of the disk?
Nope. He aged for only as long as that latest "copy" was in the Confession Dial.
Magpie 7
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2010
- Messages
- 1,717
- Reaction score
- 1
How old was Bill Murray's weatherman at the end of Groundhog Day? I thought though he ages 24 hours he's back to his original age when the day starts all over again and its the same with the Doctor every time he was rebooted.
cmiller99
Super Freak
Yeah, that's what I'd have thought too, because the older copy died and the new one was transported in. So the last copy, the survivor, might only have been a few weeks older.
Nah, that's different. I think at the end of the movie he'd been there for anywhere between 10 or 30 years depending on who you trust as a source. He had full awareness of his regeneration though.
CallMeTheDoctor
Super Freak
I think the purpose of the dial is to make him suffer. The thing is the Doctor, while enjoys mysteries, hates being unable to solve em. The fact that he gets the puzzle at the end, is a point of suffering. Then you have him having his breakdown, wanting to give up, and to always see Clara. That's a heavy thing. And just calculate him suffering a day and a half of dying. That's dying 730 billion times in those 2 billion years! And to punch your way through diamond, sheesh. While he doesn't get the concept of his being there, he does at the end; and that is all the more a heavy burden each time of his wasted life time.
I don't think it will count him as a 2 billion year old person. Also the Dial is Gallifrey technology, like the TARDIS; so my guess is that time itself may be distorted in it. I think of The Doctor's Wife when Amy saw Rory older and dying when House took over the TARDIS is an example of it. Could just be a tactic.
Overall, amazing episode! By far my favorite episode in the last 3 years, excluding The Time of the Doctor and The Day of the Doctor.
I was heartbroken over Face the Raven. Good episode to lead into this.
I don't think it will count him as a 2 billion year old person. Also the Dial is Gallifrey technology, like the TARDIS; so my guess is that time itself may be distorted in it. I think of The Doctor's Wife when Amy saw Rory older and dying when House took over the TARDIS is an example of it. Could just be a tactic.
Overall, amazing episode! By far my favorite episode in the last 3 years, excluding The Time of the Doctor and The Day of the Doctor.
I was heartbroken over Face the Raven. Good episode to lead into this.
Magpie 7
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2010
- Messages
- 1,717
- Reaction score
- 1
On the DVD commentary Harold Ramis says the day is repeated for somewhere like 1000 years or may be more, the intention being that Phil Connors number of groundhog days is infinity. He goes through so many stages, learns talents that would take 20 years to perfect and we only see a really small percentage of the days that are repeated.
cmiller99
Super Freak
That's the best source then, I'd definitely take Harold's word for it.
The Doctor wasn't aware that he was in a loop until the end of that copy's life though, whereas Phil Connors was 100% aware of every time he woke up, every time he tried to kill himself to escape. That's what I was trying to say.
Magpie 7
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2010
- Messages
- 1,717
- Reaction score
- 1
That's the best source then, I'd definitely take Harold's word for it.
The Doctor wasn't aware that he was in a loop until the end of that copy's life though, whereas Phil Connors was 100% aware of every time he woke up, every time he tried to kill himself to escape. That's what I was trying to say.
Yeah as soon as Phil gets outside and see's its still The Groundhog Day he realises but he isn't convinced, he thinks of many things such as he's dreaming or he's gone mad. But like Phil the Doctor realises that he can achieve something that would be impossible normally because of this, Phil's dating Rita and learning to play the piano or ice sculpting. The Doctor chipping away at the diamond wall, they're two different motives but the result is the same and they both escape.
BagginsOfBagEnd
Super Freak
So, another series ends! Really enjoyable as a whole....but after the beyond awesome 'Heaven Sent' last week - can't decide if I liked the finale or not, tbh feeling slightly underwhelmed on this first viewing - (maybe even a tad disappointed). 
Think I need a re-watch.
Think I need a re-watch.
Kamandi
Super Freak
They should let the Doctor travel alone for a bit before throwing a new companion in the mix.
This was a more fitting departure for Clara, the Raven episode left me cold.
This was a more fitting departure for Clara, the Raven episode left me cold.
My dvr jammed before the last 20 minutes of "Hell Bent". I reach the point where the behind the scenes is taking about the new Tardis and it freezes and asks if I want to keep or delete. 
I have no idea how it ended... and won't until this re-airs.
I have no idea how it ended... and won't until this re-airs.
Magpie 7
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2010
- Messages
- 1,717
- Reaction score
- 1
So, another series ends! Really enjoyable as a whole....but after the beyond awesome 'Heaven Sent' last week - can't decide if I liked the finale or not, tbh feeling slightly underwhelmed on this first viewing - (maybe even a tad disappointed).
I know what you mean, I really liked the finale right up to...
Clara travelling around with Me in their own TARDIS, I feel like the killed Clara off then bottled it and allowed the character to live just in case Jenna Coleman wanted to comeback at some point. The whole point of killing her off was it gave the Doctor fresh motivation against the High Council who he's fought so many times now.
Anyone think they missed a trick by not re-introducing these two in their regenerated forms...
I think Clara's appearance on Gallifrey with the first doctor makes more sense now. I can see her and Me going far back in Gallifrey's history to return the TARDIS so that she could show it to the first Doc as the one to steal. That would make it her final act before returning to the Raven to die.
BagginsOfBagEnd
Super Freak
Agreed I hated that bit to be honest! Really annoyed me tbh!!
It felt like a proper 'cop-out' and almost like something out of a fan-fiction! Hopefully it will be a while before 'Me' appears again. I also didn't like that regeneration scene. Bit worried about what 12 might regenerate into, when the time does eventually come
However the episode did have some good bits, really liked..
the return of the Sonic Screwdriver 
Gallifrey - looked visually awesome - if sadly underused
Retro TARDIS!!! FTW!!
The acting from both Capaldi and Coleman was pretty awesome
Gallifrey - looked visually awesome - if sadly underused
Retro TARDIS!!! FTW!!
The acting from both Capaldi and Coleman was pretty awesome
Still feel a bit 'meh' about the whole thing even after a re-watch - each to their own I guess! Still it's been a really great series. Back to the classic Who DVD collection now them....at least until the Christmas special!
Personally I did like it, but yeah, the Clara thing felt like a cop out. Though, to the epsiode's credit, it was really emotional. I legitimately chocked-up more than a few times. It was a bitter-sweet one.
One thing that worries me though is that they're going to with a female Doctor, and I can't say I'm a fan of that. There's no need to change everything to make it more diverse or anything like that. Sometimes the "old thing" works just as well in the modern era.
One thing that worries me though is that they're going to with a female Doctor, and I can't say I'm a fan of that. There's no need to change everything to make it more diverse or anything like that. Sometimes the "old thing" works just as well in the modern era.
Similar threads
