Is it possible? Well, anything is possible like the world ending tomorrow. But is it likely, No. They will not send you something that was returned cause I doubt they will want to deal with you returning somebody else's returned car and now that costing them more money. You'll get a fresh car from their new shipment whenever it comes in or if they have any left from this present batch.
This can't be further from the truth.
SIDESHOW DOES SEND OUT USED RETURNED PIECES - Statue Forum
I would recommend everyone read this thread in its entirety. There are multiple anecdotes of people receiving other people's (and in some cases, their own) returned pieces.