Personally, I'm not too keen on the New 52 Superman's costume due to the collar, making the whole costume look way too formal. As if he's going to a ball or something.
Maybe it'll grow on me once I've actually read the comics.
I love BB's costume and it might work in comics, but the costume's too restrictive and gave Bale headaches and stuff. Or maybe I read you wrong and you expect the movies to have this design instead?
Which I believe it to be a brilliant design for the upcoming batman movies. Simplistic design and it uses the same design as TDKR which is especially true for the cowl, which is more of a helmet.