It was ok when it came out, it was a new Predator film so there was bound to be some buzz around it. I was disappointed leaving the cinema for the first time however the second viewing was slightly better. I did get a cool looking Hot Toys Tracker figure from it I suppose.
The thing with AvP:R was that The Strause Brothers had no idea how to make a film in the first place. Fox should have never hired them or Salerno in the first place. They probably did they best their talents could manage with a crap script and in the end probs played to the fact that they were both Predator fanboys and just had a hard on making Wolf and carried on from there. To be fair, Wolf does have a big following now.
In contrast with Predators, Fox gave RR control and he ended up making a dull and funless Predator film that added nothing new to the Predator story (the blood feud could have been good but it was poorly executed and the fight was pathetic). Oh and the fact that he kept on saying in his interviews that his Preds were bigger & better than the original was just BS.